The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Winamp blighted by bug brace

Winamp 

Posted Monday 21st January 2008 15:51 GMT

It's got a long history of security bugs, but I keep using it as I think it's the best Media Player (for Audio)

Everyone complains about how bloated it's got, but you can actually install it in a fairly minimum configuration.

Even that wouldn't have helped in this case though.

hmmm 

Posted Monday 21st January 2008 16:02 GMT

Coat

"These boundary errors can be exploited to cause stack-based buffer overflows via overly long '<artist>' and '<name>' tag values in the <metadata> section,"

This means nothing to me...

Seriously we know AOL are rubbish but can they just cut Nullsoft loose so then can fix the totally broken Winamp we have these days? Its rubbish (like everything AOL have ever done), which is a shame as it used to be brilliant.

Why do I need to know this? 

Posted Monday 21st January 2008 16:09 GMT

Joke

"This means nothing to me, ahhhh...."

I'll get me coat....

Llama 

Posted Monday 21st January 2008 16:17 GMT

Coat

I thought it was Llama's that get expoited?

@Why... 

Posted Monday 21st January 2008 16:21 GMT

Dead Vulture

you picked the wrong coat, IMNSHO... you should fetch his...

@Tim 

Posted Monday 21st January 2008 16:24 GMT

Jobs Halo

May be best for Windows..

@Alistair + Dave 

Posted Monday 21st January 2008 16:26 GMT

Coat

Vieennnnnaaaaaaaaa.....

Beat me to it

@Why do I need to know this? 

Posted Monday 21st January 2008 16:39 GMT

Thumb Down

"the goggles, they do nothing"

then don't use them

yet another bad joke

/coat

Ultravox! 

Posted Monday 21st January 2008 17:05 GMT

Coat

John Foxx is the real Ultravox!

Who me ? 

Posted Monday 21st January 2008 17:39 GMT

Linux

I use Amararok so no worries there

Overly long? 

Posted Monday 21st January 2008 18:05 GMT

Coat

Like "I remember (Death in the afternoon)" ? Surely not!

We tuned the dial,

We heard the news,

And laughed,

We don't know why

Comments 

Posted Monday 21st January 2008 18:17 GMT

Coat

There has certainly been a Passionate Reply or two on this topic...

VLC for me nowadays, though I Lament the passing of WinAmp - the development team All Stood Still :-}

Winamp 

Posted Monday 21st January 2008 22:39 GMT

Personally, I think WinAMP, whilst still not what it was at it's peak is much better nowadays than it has been for years. It has many of the features back that were axed even when Nullsoft was independant so it's hard to blame AOL really.

They decided to do the whole re-write thing for some reason, god only knows why but the re-write resulted in more vulnerabilities and it caused them to take about 6 years to reimplement the features that only took them about 6months to get in the first time round.

Lament 

Posted Monday 21st January 2008 22:39 GMT

Unhappy

Poor old Midge Ure. Joe Dolce keeps Vienna off number 1, Geldof gets all the credit for Live Aid, then UltraVox gets the blame for a WinAmp bug.

Reap the wild Winamp. 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 00:26 GMT

Coat

Reap the wild Winamp.

I'll get me long mac as worn in the Vienna video.

I'm a winamp diehard, but... 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 02:05 GMT

...the main blight for me is its taking 50 second to start and 15 seconds to understand any given restore / minimize operation.

On the other hand, the built in shoutcast browser, permanently set to search for "State Of Trance", roxxors my soxxors. Or whatever the kids are saying nowadays.

@ David Wiernicki 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 02:49 GMT

50 Seconds to Start! Are you running^H^H^H^H^H crawling Vista? I have Winamp 5 and it loads the program and my 7000+ song playlist in less than 4. Granted though, my shoutcast is looking for DJ Tiesto, so that may be it... : )

I use Xine 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 03:45 GMT

Linux

it doesn't work half the time it's very safe.

Re: "I use Xine" 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 05:22 GMT

/usr/bin/play, surely....

Or you could just dd the bytes one by one into /dev/dsp :-p

Seriously though, Linux users are spoilt for choice: mplayer, sox, amarok, xmms, vlc, totem, juk ....

XMMS 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 06:30 GMT

Boffin

I still use XMMS. I've come to like it's Winamp-like interface without the 5.x bloat. I guess it's fairly forgotten now tho- I don't believe the 1.2.11 release last November had any mention on el reg?

Re:Lament 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 08:23 GMT

Lol Graham....that on just mad m spit coff ovr my kyboard and now th y that looks lik a backwards 3 dosn't work.

@ GrahamT 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 08:32 GMT

Happy

I rarely laugh out loud at comments, but that was funny as f*ck. My morning is now slightly more bearable, thank you.

Winamp no more 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 10:45 GMT

Unhappy

I've used Winamp for years but decided to swap after it seemed to develop so many bugs it started to crash randomly for me.

Maybe they need to code a little better and make it the player it once was. :(

Whats-amatta-you, eh? 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 11:25 GMT

Joke

It's-a-not so bad

shuduppayaface.

(now just to make the people cracking the ultravox fans cracking jokes feel bad the day you sat at home lamenting the fact joe dolce beat vienna to number 1 was the day I was born :)

Winamp 2 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 11:29 GMT

Alert

Ok, I still use winamp v2 (well, 2.95) and re-install from my archives each time I re-do a windows operating system (I like it, it doesn't try and sell me anything and it plays MP3's).

And for those who are not digital kleptomaniacs, there's always oldversion.com

Still the best media player there is 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 14:46 GMT

As only functioning as an MP3 player it's not the lightest but as a play everything media player then there's little to beat it on Windows IMO. Never found something it didn't know how to play.

What's the alternative, Windows Media Player, iTunes, Real Player? They're all hopeless by comparison.

Webcast: Jumpstart your Application Security initiatives