The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Polish scientists quantify perfect legs

no pictures? 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 12:06 GMT

Paris Hilton

We reg readers want samples of the various 'legs' used for comparison. Paris cause she has legs (Jobs doesn't, just a backbone)

Nice Pins 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 12:14 GMT

Pull the other one

How about... 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 12:14 GMT

long legs mean high speed (something our HUNTER-gatherer ancestors would appreciate). I do not think cholesterol/diabetes/cardiovascular disease was a serious problem when you could take your pick from cholera, malaria, plague, lions, angry mammoths/woolly rhinos, starvation, war with neighbouring tribe and all other forms of "natural" population control.

And indeed, parnter selection is often based on things the opposite thinks are hot.

Kylie's popularity amongst men 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 12:32 GMT

Happy

IMHO has less to do with the length of her legs than with her propensity to do entire dance sequences in her underwear.

Re: How about... 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 12:42 GMT

So why don't (most) men find women with moustaches attractive?

Funding 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 12:57 GMT

Who paid for this, and WHY?

Can I get a grant to find the perfect breast please?

Some men prefer... 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 13:23 GMT

Coat

...Women with fat legs. Some prefer women with thin legs. The rest prefer something in-between...

Remember.. 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 13:34 GMT

Happy

some girls are bigger than others, some girls are bigger than others, some girls mothers are bigger than other girls mothers......

Nah Not da Kylie 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 13:38 GMT

Pirate

hmm is it just me that finds Kylie really annoying? Squeaking voice and bordering on the ginger side?? Feel well overdosed on Kyliemania now and wish she would just disappear for a while.

Now Penélope Cruz thats more like it......have a google you know you wanna, and watch Volver :)

silhouette != real thing... 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 13:43 GMT

Paris Hilton

These were just silhouettes? I'm not sure I'd be interested enough to really evaluate the choices properly.. At the very least, pictures of the whole 'package' would make a better survey. Best of course would be an actual visual 'measurement' encounter, but where to find an obliging set of body doubles*??? Icon self-explanatory

What about artists's models? They are used to posing nude in front of audiences, and (probably) would not mind being judged this way...

Indeed 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 13:43 GMT

Coat

"Still, he was pretty unequivocal about why people don't much like short legs, viz: said legs are linked with "a higher risk of cardiovascular disease and type II diabetes and with higher levels of a body fat called triglyceride, which is linked to the clogging of the arteries, heart disease, strokes and insulin resistance in men".

After hundreds of thousands of years of evolution this is probably a deeply ingrained instinct.

I know that's the first thing that pops up when I gaze at a woman's legs.

Interesting but... 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 13:47 GMT

I always preferred Dannii

Bottoms 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 13:52 GMT

So, if "fat bottom girls make the rocking world go round" does that mean fat bottom girls have longer than average legs? Mind you this was sung by someone who wasn't famous for liking girls......

Not so new... 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 14:06 GMT

I've heard the same basic idea, and the same basic explanations, quite a few timnes over the years.

Repeating the tests is good science. If you can't repeat an experiment, is it ever going to be science?

And a vague general indicator of health and fitness, I can go with that. But 99.9% of our ancestors didn't know any of this medical stuff, so I really doubt the detailed list of deadly faults has any relevance

Every man knows... 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 14:06 GMT

Happy

...that the best legs are the pair descending from a mini skirt. (Anonymous today because my other half will not appreciate this sort of comment when I should be working.)

@Paul 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 14:16 GMT

Apparently the breast research has already been done, remeber reading an article in paper about it.

You just knew... 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 14:18 GMT

Happy

...when I checked my El' Reg RSS feed in Firefox I just knew that Mr Haines would be the author of such a fine article!!

Keep up the good work sir! Although I feel it only appropriate that on behalf of the El' Reg's readership I request that you use your powerful position in international journalism to request a similar study concentrating on Bulgarian airbags!

Shurley Shome Mishtake? 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 14:19 GMT

This is The Reg. Surely the byline should read "Longer than average, and attached to Paris Hilton"?

Science not working for the average man 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 14:22 GMT

Dead Vulture

And how does this knowledge improve my (already slim) chances of copulation with the oppopsite sex? Anonymous Nerd

Not a mistake at all, Stuart 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 14:53 GMT

Thumb Down

Paris has nasty legs. (Goes well with her face)

This study must have needed... 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 14:59 GMT

... a lot of leg work!

Hiltons vs Minogues? Celebrity 4some MudWrestling 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 15:09 GMT

Coat

Once a topic has been researched, follow up reseach is essencial to confirm or deny the earlier results, in this instance might I suggest lots and lots of follow up research... Oh, and may I put myself forward for one of these prestigeous testing posts when the next round of leg/breast research is being conducted?

Ah... now then AnonCow, just for the record, "I have no preference for the left leg, or for the right leg, but somewhere inbetween".

And finally, I seem to remember reading someplace that the ideal length for a pair of legs is, "long enough to reach the ground".

Now then, where's my CAMELskin coat?

Presumably, then, 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 18:23 GMT

Thumb Up

...if attractive legs are 5% longer than average, humans will select each generation to have legs relatively longer than the last. Therefore, the leg-vs-body ratio will increase ad infinitum.

This suggests that rather than huge heads with big eyeballs, pop-culture representations of aliens should actually consist of tiny torsos on top of fifteen-foot-long gams. Excellent.

What about 

Posted Thursday 17th January 2008 23:14 GMT

Happy

if they belong to a blonde on a beach, with a laptop?

Re: long legs mean high speed 

Posted Friday 18th January 2008 02:30 GMT

Linux

Right. But that does not fit the data, because the 10% longer legs (instead of 5%, the winners) were *less* attractive.

"But 99.9% of our ancestors didn't know any of this medical stuff, so I really doubt the detailed list of deadly faults has any relevance"

Er, that's not really how evolution works, mate... You don't need to be choosing the characteristic (consciously or not) -- otherwise non-human organisms wouldn't evolve, right? If you choose the "good" one (and the propensity to make that choice is inheritable), your descendants will be better off than those who do the "wrong" choice. Not that I really have a reason to think this particular case of the longer legs has anything to do with that anyway...

Penguins have quite short legs.

Stop! Stop! 

Posted Friday 18th January 2008 09:44 GMT

Stop

You're confirming the unfair prejudice that geeks are obsessed with the body of Members Of The Appropriate Sex!

@long legs mean high speed 

Posted Monday 21st January 2008 10:45 GMT

Long legs don’t necessarily mean high speed because you would need more muscle to move those long levers effectively. In other words, 5% more can mean more speed, but 10% more and you are probably getting the reverse effect.

@@long legs mean high speed 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 13:40 GMT

Boffin

Just look at Peter Crouch and the 'Bambi on Ice' effect.

Don’t Miss