Feeds

US TKOs Antigua in bizarre WTO arbitration decision

Dispute strangely reaches climax

Choosing a cloud hosting partner with confidence

The long-running dispute between little Antigua and the mighty US over the cross border provision of gaming services came to a head this morning, with the announcement of a US $21 mil award in Antigua’s favor. The amount was quite a bit less than the $3.4 bil demanded by the Antiguans, but considerably more than the $500,000 offered by the US.

The panel agreed with Antigua that it had no effective trade sanctions against the United States other than to suspend its WTO obligations to the United States in respect of copyrights, trademarks and other forms of intellectual property. Antigua now has the right to produce counterfeit copies of Hollywood movies, Microsoft software, or whatnot to satisfy the judgment.

The arbitrators assessed Antigua’s level of damages based upon a hypothetical form of compliance proposed by the United States, rather than through the withdrawal of the overall prohibition - a prohibition that in fact has been expanded in the years since Antigua initially brought the case through the passage of the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act, which targeted banks and other financial institutions, and provided for a whole new series of domestic carve-outs. In light of the way the US has been thumbing its nose at previous WTO rulings in the case, the feeble award comes as a definite shock.

In a conference call, Mark Mendel, Antigua’s lead attorney, referred to the decision to use a hypothetical on gambling on horse racing estimate of damages rather than actual damages as ”unsound” and “incredible.”

"There was never an assessment that the only discrimination was in horse racing. I think it's a horrible ruling."

“It’s an extraordinary document. It’ll have academics and lawyers talking for years. First off, just the length. The previous record was 52 pages. Second, the existence of a dissenting opinion. There’s never been a dissenting opinion in an Article 22 hearing.”

Although the arbitrators were tasked only with assessing damages - after all, Antigua had already won, and won big - two of the three arbitrators managed to knee-cap the prior compliance panel ruling by resorting to the Article 22 principle of "reasonably expected compliance," and adopting the approach sought by the US. The majority ruling essentially gutted the prior compliance panel ruling by adopting the US position of what constitutes reasonableness under the circumstances.

This decision also resulted in an unprecedented disagreement among the arbitrators, with one panelist dissenting from the approach adopted by the other two members over the unprecedented use of the Article 22 provision to eviscerate a prior compliance panel decision.

"What kind of precedent does this set?" asked Mendel.

Mendel did express satisfaction that the panel approved Antigua’s right to cross-retaliate by suspension of intellectual property rights of United States business interests. He expressed notably less satisfaction with the amount of damages assessed. In a move sure to throw fuel on the fire of this controversial trade dispute, the arbitrators decided on the $21 mil figure based solely on what Antigua’s hypothetical share of the US online horse racing market, although previous rulings had interpreted Antigua's trade rights far more broadly.

“I find it astonishing that two of the three panelists would in essence grant the United States the benefit of a hypothetical method of compliance most favorable to the American side in assessing Antigua’s level of trade impairment. What appears to have been done here is assuming a form of compliance that has not happened and probably will not happen without giving Antigua the ability to contest the method under the WTO’s normal procedures,” he added.

Unlike other WTO rulings, awards of arbitrators are not subject to review by the Appellate Body of the WTO. However, were internet gambling to continue to expand in the US - as seems almost certain - Antigua would have the right to return to the WTO to reassess the damage award. Antigua's position will also have to be revisited as the US continues its Article 21 proceedings to withdraw gambling services from its WTO commitments.

While expressing dismay at the low number and the dodgy method by which it was reached, Mendel tried to stay upbeat about what the future has in store.

“I hope that the United States government will now see the wisdom in reaching some accommodation with Antigua over this dispute and look forward to seeing efforts in this regard.”®

Burke Hansen, attorney at large, heads a San Francisco law office

Business security measures using SSL

More from The Register

next story
Hey, Scots. Microsoft's Bing thinks you'll vote NO to independence
World's top Google-finding website calls it for the UK
Phones 4u slips into administration after EE cuts ties with Brit mobe retailer
More than 5,500 jobs could be axed if rescue mission fails
Apple CEO Tim Cook: TV is TERRIBLE and stuck in the 1970s
The iKing thinks telly is far too fiddly and ugly – basically, iTunes
Israeli spies rebel over mass-snooping on innocent Palestinians
'Disciplinary treatment will be sharp and clear' vow spy-chiefs
Huawei ditches new Windows Phone mobe plans, blames poor sales
Giganto mobe firm slams door shut on Microsoft. OH DEAR
Phones 4u website DIES as wounded mobe retailer struggles to stay above water
Founder blames 'ruthless network partners' for implosion
Found inside ISIS terror chap's laptop: CELINE DION tunes
REPORT: Stash of terrorist material found in Syria Dell box
OECD lashes out at tax avoiding globocorps' location-flipping antics
You hear that, Amazon, Google, Microsoft et al?
prev story

Whitepapers

Providing a secure and efficient Helpdesk
A single remote control platform for user support is be key to providing an efficient helpdesk. Retain full control over the way in which screen and keystroke data is transmitted.
Saudi Petroleum chooses Tegile storage solution
A storage solution that addresses company growth and performance for business-critical applications of caseware archive and search along with other key operational systems.
Security and trust: The backbone of doing business over the internet
Explores the current state of website security and the contributions Symantec is making to help organizations protect critical data and build trust with customers.
Reg Reader Research: SaaS based Email and Office Productivity Tools
Read this Reg reader report which provides advice and guidance for SMBs towards the use of SaaS based email and Office productivity tools.
Security for virtualized datacentres
Legacy security solutions are inefficient due to the architectural differences between physical and virtual environments.