The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Google opens Maps for editing

why stop there? 

Posted Thursday 22nd November 2007 10:47 GMT

Stop

why stop there? i can think of loads of place names that are spelt wrong or in the wrong place altogether up here in north wales. there are even some roads missing completely

Silly Idea 

Posted Thursday 22nd November 2007 10:51 GMT

Thumb Up

I wonder what would happen if we moved Parliament about 50 metres south then?

What about bigger mistakes? 

Posted Thursday 22nd November 2007 10:55 GMT

Thumb Down

Will there be a way to adjust it so that it doesn't think every address in Sheffield is 'Norton, Sheffield'? I doubt it, it's been incorrect since the launch of the service now.

@Silly Idea 

Posted Thursday 22nd November 2007 11:12 GMT

Joke

Well the Wets on the tory front bench would feel right at home with that.

The power of Google 

Posted Thursday 22nd November 2007 11:14 GMT

I hope that the user-editable Google maps include a drag-and-drop facility. Then we can drag the British Isles closer to the equator during the winter months, and it won't be so dark and damp and dismal.

More stuff to add 

Posted Thursday 22nd November 2007 11:18 GMT

Paris Hilton

I'd appreciate being able to add in roads, for example, the one where I live (so that visitors could find us). Also details of the usability of roads, you know, like impassable for large vehicles; steep, single track with no passing places; potholed to resemble Bosnia/Iraq; Closed for resurfacing; floods easily;

Paris angle: Could give her location like that machine on last weeks Mighty Boosh

Why give the data to Google? 

Posted Thursday 22nd November 2007 11:32 GMT

Go

It would make more sense to contribute it to OpenStreetMap (http://www.openstreetmap.org/), so at least you get to own the data and use it how you like later.

I'm astonished how well OpenStreetMap are doing, I thought it would never take off.

Google not first shocker! 

Posted Thursday 22nd November 2007 11:34 GMT

There is already an editable map on the Internet.

http://www.openstreetmap.org

Perth 

Posted Thursday 22nd November 2007 11:39 GMT

And how about google.co.uk/maps showing the UK Perth rather than Australian! Problem is, it's not Google who is in control of a lot of the base data. But they are in a position to correct mistakes by their mapping suppliers.

Will user contributed data be copyrighted ? 

Posted Thursday 22nd November 2007 11:54 GMT

Or will it be free (as in speech) in the same way openstreetmap is?

Sensible Idea 

Posted Thursday 22nd November 2007 12:05 GMT

Thumb Up

This feature is a sensible step and will improve the accuracy of searches for Google Local, especially in areas with 'large' postcode footprints (retail parks, rural areas etc).

The adding of roads that aren't currently shown will come in, but it all depends on the type of data purchased by Google, just because it's there doesn't mean it will be purchased and displayed. Try ViaMichelin or similar (www.viamichelin.co.uk) for more detailed rural coverage.

This repositioning of POI is going to be a blessing for anyone who regularly has to travel to out of the way places!

Why? 

Posted Thursday 22nd November 2007 12:07 GMT

IT Angle

We've got wikimapia.org and lots of other sites.

Alternatively... 

Posted Thursday 22nd November 2007 12:48 GMT

Go

Let us edit street names they have gotten blatantly wrong! I know of several streets with incorrect names in google maps/google earth!

London village 

Posted Thursday 22nd November 2007 13:00 GMT

Happy

I love the way OSM describes London:

"City London [nl:Londen] [fr:Londres] [fi:Lontoo] [la:Londinium] [cy:Llundain], about 31km south-east of St Albans"

And Photos too 

Posted Friday 23rd November 2007 09:46 GMT

I would love to be able to move the photo flags to the correct locations. Tis annoying researching a holiday spot to find that the "snaps" are wildly misplaced. Must annoy the locals as well.

Don’t Miss

SunSun's surviving staff hit with 'motivation' missive

Exclusive Code: Your solace, our savior

Ubuntu teaser Ubuntu's Karmic Koala bares fangs at Windows 7

Review Shuttleworthian scrap

AppleChange your views: OS X tags exploited

Mac Secrets Apple windows insider

JavaSun preps cell-phone Java plan for netbooks

OpenWorld 09 Modules not globules