The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Lily Allen 'in talks' to become Doctor Who's assistant

It's in the Sun... 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 10:17 GMT

...so it must be true.

"Lily is multi-talented" 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 10:20 GMT

Paris Hilton

Like Paris? :-)

okay... 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 10:23 GMT

Thumb Down

now, let me begin by saying i don't really have anything against her; i actually like some of her music.

BUT this bullshit of 'Lily can do anything. save the world, even!' has got to fucking stop!

Time for a regeneration? 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 10:27 GMT

Unhappy

"With Lily and someone younger and edgier in the lead role it could open up the show to a new, trendier crowd."

Well that's Dr. Who ruined forever then. Oh well, it was good while it lasted.

"Quick watch out for that space shark.. 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 10:32 GMT

..we have no choice Dr, we gotta jump it"

weeeeee...

"Lily is multi-talented" 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 10:39 GMT

She can pick her nose AND tie her laces.

The Nags Head 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 10:42 GMT

I always get Lily Allen and Lily Savage mixed up. Is it the blonde one?

Oi Lilly - NO 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 10:42 GMT

Unhappy

If your that ruddy good, write your own show - heh.

Well 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 10:43 GMT

Thumb Down

I object to her very existence on the basis of her fathers existence.

But then which is worse? Catherine "I've seen dead fish with more talent" Tate or Lily "I'm only famous because I've got a famous/unfunny/unpleasant human being dad" Allen?

Dearie me.... 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 10:53 GMT

IT Angle

....the BBC's obsession with Lilly Allen knows no bounds does it? Methinks she may well be 'pleasuring' someone senior (allegedly!) to secure this seemingly wall-to-wall coverage.

Either that or they wouldn't mind a bit of pleasuring from her (yuk!).

Lily is multi nippled also 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 10:57 GMT

Alien

Perhaps her third nipple will be used to fend off the last of the daleks?

@that Anonymous Coward 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 10:59 GMT

Flame

"...... i actually like some of her music."

Yeah, that's easy to say anonymously. Now reiterate that with your identity disclosed. I dare you.

For the love of god 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 11:05 GMT

Stop

The Sun has a proven track record of being wrong. Don't encourage them.

If the doctor is to be replaced 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 11:12 GMT

I vote John Simm, though it's hard to see how they'd explain the new doctor looking exactly like the Master (unless he was feeling guilty about engineering his demise and chose to look like him).

Dr. R.I.P. 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 11:15 GMT

Alert

Just as you thought it couldn't get any worse, it does! The Tardis is going to be the biggest talent vacuum in the universe, Tate, Allen, Ifans added together might make it to one Langford ( the accepted unit of Whovian talent ).

All it needs is a nice 'Bertie Basset' baddie to complete the set...

of course its all part of the plot 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 11:35 GMT

Happy

a couple of series and numerous strange choices for Doctors and Assistants later we find that the biggest baddie ever turns out to be orchestrating the whole thing and the Dr is just a re-animated dead timelord :)

Acting Experience? 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 11:36 GMT

Billie Piper didn't use Dr Who "for her transition from music to acting" - she went to theatre school, and had already starred in a number of BBC plays before getting the role of Rose.

What acting experience does Lily have?

I can't help feeling that the "source" is really Lily's agent...

Leave Catherine Tate alone 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 11:41 GMT

She'll make an excellent companion. I already have some spoilers of the episodes that have been written around her nuanced and multi-faceted character.

"Silence is Golden" - when a race of intergalactic librarians threaten London with permanent silence, the only person who can drive them away is a woman with a really annoying voice who only has one volume setting - but where will the Doctor find one of those?

"Novelty Fair" - when a race of thrill-seeking aliens threaten London with being turned into their white-knuckle fun-fair, the only person who can drive them away is a woman who can turn anything into a boring, unfunny catchphrase within two or three repetitions - but where will the Doctor find one of those?

"The Doctor's Dalliances" - when Martha Jones unexpectedly returns she and Donna immediately come into conflict. Written by RTD this episode will shock viewers with the subtle nuance it applies to harpy-like screeching and blowjob gags.

"Nostalgia ain't what it used to be" - 45 minutes of a target being displayed on the screen under the words "The fan must be punished. Strike the screen with your forehead." For accessibility purposes, instructions will be squawked by Catherine Tate throughout.

My spies also report that halfway through the series the TARDIS will see the introduction of a wacky new character, the Doctor's nephew Scrappy-Doc! Hijinks ensue!

Lily who? 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 11:42 GMT

Paris Hilton

I had to look her up. Not that I'd ever accuse wikipedia of being a reliable source, but it does have some interesting snippets...

"After her family went to Ibiza on vacation ... She earned money by ... dealing in ecstasy."

"Allen was rejected by several labels, which she attributed to her drinking..."

"Allen studied horticulture with the intent of becoming a florist but changed her mind..."

"I really want to explore the acting route more, but nothing which involves me taking my clothes off. ... I just want to do proper cool stuff. I definitely feel the time is right to explore acting"

Proper cool stuff. Oh dear, oh dear, what has Dr. Who come to. Next thing he'll be reincarnated as a west indian rapper with gold chains...

On the positive side, though:

"She has also called Bob Geldof a "cunt""

"She also said that everyone who bought Paris Hilton's debut album should be killed off"

but even so :(

Billie Piper - a pedant writes 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 12:07 GMT

Paris Hilton

Billie went to the Sylvia Young Theatre School and appeared on Scratchy & Co (man, that was *bad* Saturday morning TV) before assaulting us with 'Because We Want To', so she went from 'acting' to 'music' and then back to 'acting'.

Multitalented?!?! 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 12:30 GMT

Flame

If someone can find a single talent in Lily Allen, they're doing a damn sight better than I've managed so far. Can't sing, can't write decent songs, and isn't even particularly attractive (that slack-jawed chavette look does nothing for me). Still and all, she's better than Paris in that at least she writes *some* songs.

Adding another Paris Hilton angle. I was at a Bob Brozman gig last night, and he reckoned that you could hear the drumbeats in pop going "stoo-pid-stoo-pid-stoo-pid-stoo-pid". And repeated phrase throughout the gig: "Don't buy Paris Hilton's new record, it'll make you stupid." (Off-topic: If Bob is gigging in your area, get there and see him. Nuttier than squirrel crap, but a pure genius musician.)

Ifans? 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 12:34 GMT

Jobs Horns

I think Rhys Ifans would be a bloody hilarious Dr. Who. Bring out a nice hilarious dark side.

Oh dear gods.... 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 12:46 GMT

Stop

Having no idea who Lilly Allen is, I went to her website and my ears were assaulted by some incredibly awful "singing".

If that's any measure of her acting talent then it seems the producers of Dr Who are definitely trying to kill off the show :-(

No wai! 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 12:49 GMT

Stop

Are the BBC trying alienate the core audience? What would she bring to the table for the average Dr. Who fan (As opposed to the casual watcher and chav brigade)?

Can't see it happening myself, but I'm not putting it past the BBC to be looney enough to try and make this one fly...

trendier audience? 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 12:49 GMT

OMG if this is what Who is going to be aimed at we might all just as well join My Space or Bebo and chuck the TV out of the window. I'd rather stick knitting needles in my eyes than watch more talentless totty posing around the place.

Lilly Who? Might just as well get V Beckham signed up and have done with it.

The Adventures of Sarah Jane on the beebies channel on Sundays is waaay better and she's even got K-9 around.

Grumpy, moi?

@James 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 13:28 GMT

Thumb Up

Damn you. Now the monitor's obscured by a fine mist of tea...

'Lily is multi-talented' 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 13:32 GMT

She really is - ubiquitous AND annoying.

but... kylie 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 13:41 GMT

Coat

"And as an Xmas treat, Kylie Minogue will play Astrid the Titanic waitress"

Thats a little bit of an unfair judgement on old Kylie, shes actually quite a petite lass! :)

Havent we yet learned that The Sun Is NOT a source of Dr Who info. 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 13:46 GMT

Dead Vulture

Lets see, Dr Who isnt canceled, RTD isnt leaving, etc etc. Please stop reprinting this trash, and stick to real sources please.

Who Cares? 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 14:03 GMT

Bring back Tom Baker!

The doctor was always better as an older man.

As for bloody talentless Lily Allen words fail me. I can only assume Amy Wino was not available...

The Jury's out on Catherine Tate, but I'm expecting to be underwhelmed. She (IMHO) fails miserably to be funny because everything she does is predictable and over acted. I think she now should officially take over the mantle of "Britain's unfunniest comedienne" from Jennifer Saunders. It's quite an acheivement considering how dire most of them are. Jo Brand is the only one who makes me laugh.

Cant be worse than... 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 14:18 GMT

Boffin

Lily Allen can do a worse job than Catherine Tate's likely to do

David Tennant 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 14:37 GMT

..is Timmy Mallet on speed and a crap """""actor""""".

RTD 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 14:51 GMT

Unhappy

As long as RTD is in charge, thing's will get worse.

Sorry to requote but... 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 16:19 GMT

Thumb Down

"The insider concluded: "With Lily and someone younger and edgier in the lead role it could open up the show to a new, trendier crowd.""

That sounds remarkably like Krusty the Clown's marketing people in an episode that was on just last night. It's when Krusty decides he has to quit cos he can't stand all the meddling marketing types trying to make things more popular by finding more and more "lowest common denominator" things for him to do.

*sigh* I'd settle for Colin Baker (and Peri) back, never mind Tom.

Also, the Sun is shit. No idea about this Lily character is, is she the junkie alcoholic one that we keep hearing about?

NO OH NO OH NO OH NO!!!!!! (EOM) 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 16:56 GMT

(EOM)

When will people learn... 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 17:19 GMT

Flame

...to ignore articles that have bollox like this in them: "With Lily and someone younger and edgier in the lead role it could open up the show to a new, trendier crowd."

This is pure flame-bait and almost certainly never uttered by this 'insider', if he/she/it/whatever even exists at all. The show is already the trendiest thing BBC have produced for 200 years or so, and Tennant is hardly a poster-boy for octogenarian has-beens, is he?

Dr who 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 22:07 GMT

It's not Shipman so I give in. Who is it?

I am much older than her dad 

Posted Tuesday 13th November 2007 22:07 GMT

Happy

and i think she is great!

@Steven Walker 

Posted Wednesday 14th November 2007 10:59 GMT

Joke

Are you her Mum?

Reminds me of this joke: Knock, knock...

@Peter Yates 

Posted Wednesday 14th November 2007 12:28 GMT

You obviously didn't see Ronni Ancona & Co if you think Saunders ever was the unfunniest comedienne. But Catherine Tate is without doubt worse than both of them, being both unfunny and ubiquitous (though at least from what I've seen of her show, it's not a bigoted hatefest as Little Britain is).

Saunders is merely mediocre with some bright moments. Vivienne Vyle, her last vehicle that ended last week, was very average. It had its good bits (the hideous female producer speaking broken Spanish down the phone to her toddler because it learnt to talk from her foreign nanny was original and laugh-out-loud funny) balanced by an appallingly cheap ending, so the whole thing averaged out to, well, average. British sit-com and sketch comedy seems to be a dead loss at the moment, thankfully our satirists haven't lost it yet.

Don’t Miss