The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Law & Order takes on Second Life

One of the best US series 

Posted Monday 8th October 2007 10:08 GMT

Coat

Not sure of the second life angle, but I can highly recommend L&O:SVU (and the grand-daddy, L&O "classic") as being one the best examples of US drama in years. Having been hooked since 2002, and watched all the back episodes since, I can confidently state that even a mediocre episode (by their own high standards) beats anything UK TV has shown into a cocked hat.

And Mariska Hargitay is quite a looker ....

game stories 

Posted Monday 8th October 2007 10:34 GMT

Dead Vulture

A computer game story was also featured in CSI Miami at some stage in previous series, where some teenagers got so hooked on a game they decided to re-live it. the CSI's then played the game to solve the mystery of where they will strike next

trouble is, stories like that give the "computer games rot kids minds" people ammunition!

Law & Order 

Posted Monday 8th October 2007 10:39 GMT

It's an odd sensation when you suddenly realise an episode is "inspired by" something you actually know about. There was one episode based on Stephen Hawking's "carer problems", one based on the complicated life of US architect Louis Kahn, and one about folk who want to cut off their own limbs which was triggered by such a case in Falkirk.

They do seem to make their computer references more realistic than most.

And now Chris Noth & Annabelle Sciorra join Criminal Intent. Good-o.

Dumb Innocents 

Posted Monday 8th October 2007 11:25 GMT

"trouble is, stories like that give the "computer games rot kids minds" people ammunition!"

Some would say that it does and they do, Nick, and the sooner the dangers are outed the sooner they will be taken out of the Game.

"Positive light"? 

Posted Monday 8th October 2007 11:43 GMT

> Linden Labs and their ilk can rest easy though, as the creators of the virtual world, Another Universe, are painted in a positive light as they willingly assist the detectives in their investigation.

As long as that "willing assistance" doesn't mean turning over the private data of all their customers so the Police can go trawling through it at will and maybe identify a few "sex offenders" whilst they're at it...

South Park 

Posted Monday 8th October 2007 11:44 GMT

Thumb Up

I think South Park has the best game story.... Make Love Not War-craft.

bet it would be as good 

Posted Monday 8th October 2007 13:02 GMT

... as the WoW south park episode... that showed some of the dangers of spending too much time in these virtual worlds.

@Graham Marsden 

Posted Monday 8th October 2007 13:35 GMT

Thumb Up

To be fair, L&O scripts are very balanced, and I'm consistently surprised at the frank opinions the characters - anti gitmo, anti patriot act, pro compassionate (medical) marijuana. And (espcially L&O) there aer quite often fascinating constitutional issues debated with some interesting views ....

courtesay of The Simpsons 

Posted Monday 8th October 2007 14:41 GMT

Law & Order: Elevator Inspectors Unit

"Just as we suspected, the light has gone out on one of the buttons!"

One interesting action 

Posted Monday 8th October 2007 21:32 GMT

Was when the web people made the sun rise a bunch of hours early. Something along the lines of "This is going to freak out a whole bunch of people". Somehow it is easy to have the sun rise at midnight in a computer. Can't do that in the real world.

Good story line in any event. Always at the top of the TiVo priority list.

No icons here!!

@ Anonymous Coward 

Posted Tuesday 9th October 2007 06:21 GMT

"I can confidently state that even a mediocre episode (by their own high standards) beats anything UK TV has shown into a cocked hat."

You have GOT to be joking!

L & O is the best (sorry - the only half-decent) US show, but to say that it beats anything from the UK into a cocked hat simply boggles the mind!

There are plenty of shows on either side of the pond which are pure and simple rubbish, no doubt about it, but I would certainly prefer what the UK has to offer over what the US has so often stolen from the UK and usually ruined in the process. CSI(put your own town's name here) being a prime example.

L & O is one which runs counter to this trend (All in the Family, Three's Company, Sanford and Son etc.) and has an enviable record of dealing with current themes in an intelligent manner. Methinks Dick Wolf(?), the producer, is the probable reason for their better-than-most track record. I can only hope that it is he who produces the inevitable re-make of Red Cap!

@Norman Bowring 

Posted Tuesday 9th October 2007 08:07 GMT

I prefer to remain anonymous as given the great record that is the internet, it might save embaressment in the future ... I wasn't attacking anyone personally.

However, back on track. L&O is a regular series - 24 episodes a season. It's been going since 1991, and over that time I can't recall a dreadful episode. L&O:Criminal Intent can get a bit far-fetched at times. And L&O:SVU sometimes plays a bit too much on the heart strings. But the original just keeps on. I can't think of anything in the UK that can be compared on a like-for-like basis.

"Life On Mars" was original, true. And fun. But it was a 2-season special. What else is there ? "The Bill" ?

WRT "CSI", I will grant that "CSI:NY" and "CSI:Miami" are <General Melchett>absolutely dreadful</General Melchett> but thats because Bill Petersen washed his hands of them.

Anyway, it's all down to personal taste ...

Red Cap 

Posted Tuesday 9th October 2007 18:08 GMT

Wasnt the current version already a re-make of a 1960's show?

Don’t Miss