A Dutch judge has declared the use of Nedap e-voting machines in recent Dutch elections unlawful.

The 9,000 Nedap-made machines used in the November and March elections were not adequately authorised and at least one type of Nedap machine wasn't even certified. Despite the ruling, the election results will remain valid.

The Dutch government decided last week to pull to plug on the e-voting venture, citing the lack of a paper trail as its biggest shortcoming. Until an automated paper counting solution can be deployed, the Dutch will have to revert back to the red pencil. Citizens of the Dutch town of Utrecht will elect a new Mayor next week in the traditional manner.

Nedap says the decision won't affect its business. As the sole supplier of e-voting machines in the Netherlands it is likely to introduce more solid machines in the near future. At least one Dutch analyst called the situation "a blessing in disguise" for Nedap. Nedap stresses that reverting back to pen and paper isn't the solution.

Voters in Hamburg are to use a digital pen when casting their votes in the state parliament election next February. With the digital pen, which contains a small camera, voters can still use paper ballots and mark them with crosses as before. ®

Related stories

• Dutch ban voting computers over eavesdropping fear (20 May 2008)
• UK elections vulnerable to fraud - e-voting no solution (28 April 2008)
• RSA Where were you when you learned e-voting was unreliable? (11 April 2008)
• German hackers fight electronic voting (8 January 2008)
• E-voting vendor sued over machine change (21 November 2007)
• Government rejects retreat on e-voting (13 November 2007)
• Dutch FOI disclosures reveal the odd business of evoting (17 March 2007)
• 1,200 Dutch e-voting machines vulnerable to hacking (31 October 2006)
• Play chess on your nearest e-voting machine (5 October 2006)
• E-voting security: getting it right (8 July 2004)
• E-voting security: looking good on paper? (7 July 2004)
• Dutch e-voting software goes open source (23 June 2004)