The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: US allows import of Qualcomm chips

This is wrong 

Posted Thursday 13th September 2007 19:00 GMT

These companies are contributing to infringement of Broadcom's rights, by selling this equipment.

This is a hazard of dealing with a company known to bully people with their IP lawyers. It's about time they got smacked, and people using their chips should get smacked too for giving them money and supporting them.

Failure of US 

Posted Friday 14th September 2007 09:33 GMT

Surely this ridiculous and bizarre situation is an end-result of the failure of the US authorities to effectively legislate or enforce intellectual property laws?

It makes perfect sense 

Posted Friday 14th September 2007 11:59 GMT

It might seem counterintuitive, but it makes sense that the manufacturers using Qualcomm's chips wouldn't have been in the position to know that the chips infringed on a Broadcom's patents.

by analogy 

Posted Friday 14th September 2007 18:04 GMT

If it comes to light that you've unwittingly purchased a stolen car, do they let you keep it?

Should they let you keep it, even if the neighborhood gas station complains they won't sell as much gas as they'd hoped to if you aren't allowed to keep the stolen car?

Should we, as a society, stop creating all these examples that say it's OK to break the rules if breaking the rules makes enough money?

Would you say this is roughly analogous to the situation involving Qualcomm (the car thief), the phone manufacturer's (you), and AT&T (the gas station)?

Don’t Miss

Dollar101 uses for a former merchant banker

Comment Innovators who work out the best one will make a killing

The Year in Operating Systems: No battle of big ideas

Small change for 2009

Photography: Yes, you have rights

Comment Unless the police say you haven't

Enormous HP box spotted from space

Exclusive pics of Peterborough packaging pandemonium