By Henry GomersallPosted Friday 10th August 2007 09:32 GMT
You miss the point that everybody in the magical world is fabulously wealthy, due to the incredible efficiency of everything. For this reason, its not wealth of money but wealth of soul that the Weasley brothers are after. The magical world's economy should be thought of with an eye to the Star Trek economy, rather than our economy.
By Chris MorrisonPosted Friday 10th August 2007 09:42 GMT
.....where's the IT angle.... :-)
I hate harry potter so i haven't actually read this article. If it happens to be about some bloke called Harry who's an IT manager from Ipswitch who's done something newsworthy then I apologise!
By Lexx GreatrexPosted Friday 10th August 2007 10:27 GMT
1. Percy Weasley was not a "sympathiser with the Death Eaters" but merely a sycophantic brown nose to the minister; who himself was decieved by, but by no means sympathetic with the death eaters.
2. I am beginning to suspect that the author of this article hasn't actually read the Deathly Hallows yet. Arthur Weasley no longer has two tearaway sons. Fred was killed by a death eater at the final battle in Hogwarts.
3. This whole paragraph, apart from being a grammatical travesty, makes absolutely no sense at all. Even after the fifth read: "Lord Peter Wimsey became an amateur sleuth. And he was needed. And in the world of Harry Potter, such people are, clearly, going to be equally vital to the future. Such enforcers of Magic Law as exist have shown themselves to be easily daunted by authority, which seems to desire nothing more than a quiet life, and by bureaucracy which takes intervention in people's private lives as an absolute right, and has powers which no mere computer database or ID card could ever convey."
4. Once again Reg writers were able to choose a headline "Harry Potter and the Virus of Doom" which bears absolutely no meaningful relationship to the article whatsoever. What are you feeding these people Reg?
By Kevin EastmanPosted Friday 10th August 2007 12:25 GMT
Has an avid reader of Harry Potter and Harry Potter fan fics (yes, I am an adult and admit to it), I know just the fan fic author to suggest it to. Hmm, hate to see Harry piss off the BOFH or pfy. I wonder if Simon would have a problem of someone were to write a cross over story. LOL
By amanfromMarsPosted Friday 10th August 2007 13:41 GMT
"Yes, Minister for Magic
By Robert Synnott
Posted Friday 10th August 2007 12:57 GMT
Oh, it would be fun."
And QuITe a Doddle if ITs Authors are A'Mused.
Does J.K. want to teach IT Boffins her Tricks........ for AI Walk on the Wild Side, Red, Raw and Raunchy.
Proceed with All Due Care and Attention to dDetail. Can Serious improve your WellBeing...... and Tax Greatly the Heart. :-)..... a Veritable Pump of Sumptuous Gold.
By Anonymous CowardPosted Friday 10th August 2007 14:06 GMT
So the penultimate solution to going from a hyperactive, heroic life, is becoming a 2-bit gumshoe? No wonder so many retirees die soon after leaving active, working lives. How about research, another adventure, or Harry enjoying the rewards of raising a family and giving them everything he was denied in life, then moving on to teaching, or anything else. Surely there's got to be something better for an intelligent, creative, and vital being to do than being an amateur sleuth? There are many ways to live a life/better the world. YMMV.
By Anonymous CowardPosted Friday 10th August 2007 14:29 GMT
Please, oh please , share wathever you took before writing this "article". I mean, come on, it´s acceptable for a personal blog perhaps, but I don´t quite see it as ElReg material.
By Saucerhead TharpePosted Friday 10th August 2007 15:11 GMT
As well as Glen Cook's Chandleresque source material that provides such unlikely names as Morley Dotes, there is Lord Darcy by Randall Garrett. He didn't have any magical talent, but his assistant was a Forensic Sorceror.
2. I am beginning to suspect that the author of this article hasn't actually read the Deathly Hallows yet. Arthur Weasley no longer has two tearaway sons. Fred was killed by a death eater at the final battle in Hogwarts.
---
Congrats, you managed to introduce spoilers into an otherwise spoiler-free article.
If we discount the "harry has a wife" and "harry is still alive" bits.
By Morely DotesPosted Friday 10th August 2007 16:28 GMT
"And what about spam? Is there any sign that conventional Muggle techniques are coping? Yes, if you believe Sophos wizard Graham Cluley, but not if you check my inbox."
Want to end spam? Kill a spammer. Nothing else seems to stop them. Not prison, not bankruptcy, not even ridicule nor hacking of their systems.
Make it legal to kill spammers, and the problem will be solved before 2010.
By The Mighty SpangPosted Friday 10th August 2007 16:47 GMT
what next, a critical look at the story in "where's spot?"
hp seems to be an incredibly long version of "the karate kid" with added rubbish. i mean quidditch. makes american football seem like a sensible sport.
By Steven HewitttPosted Saturday 11th August 2007 22:15 GMT
"IT and Tech/Sci News"
WTF is this shite?!
I don't read Harry Potter (my balls have dropped, thus I'm too old to read it), but surely this article is based on:
1. Author has taken far too many drugs before going to the keyboard
2. El Reg is desperate for search hits on Google so they're just going to start typing any old popular bollocks out there with lots of keywords but create a mythical IT angle to it
3. Editor has taken far too many drunk and told the staff to create a random article, and the shittest one with the least technical angle wins and goes on the site (with exemption from the rounds down the pub later)
4. All of the above as it's Friday and El Reg wants to piss off the readers so something funny appears in the comments to fill the letters article?
By Anonymous CowardPosted Sunday 12th August 2007 05:13 GMT
Harry isn't quite so intelligent as most people think... afterall he did well at defence against the dark arts + quidditch but was merely mediocre at virtually everything else.
Some people say Harry went on to be an International Quidditch star... an occupation in my opinion well suited to this guy.
But then again, your article *did* require an IT angle of some sort :)
By |333173|3|_||3Posted Sunday 12th August 2007 16:11 GMT
I thought it was mentioned somewhere he becomes Head of the Auror Office, making Ginny his immediate superior. I can see him as a sort of Dirty Harry, blasting his way through walls, pointing his wand at suspects and grinning "Make my F*cking day" at them.
By Anonymous CowardPosted Monday 13th August 2007 11:47 GMT
>2. I am beginning to suspect that the author of this article hasn't actually read the >Deathly Hallows yet. Arthur Weasley no longer has two tearaway sons. Fred was >killed by a death eater at the final battle in Hogwarts.
Oh I hate amateur pedants. The 2 tearaway sons are George and Ron, in an online Q&A JKR revealed they continue the business together. Could it be the author knows more than you? Bah, nothing worse than being pedantic and wrong ;)
By Andy GoodairPosted Monday 13th August 2007 12:48 GMT
Oh dear! The two Weasley's who formed the business were Fred and George; as was correctly pointed out, Fred is now dead and George turned out not to have a good ear for business opportunities.
Ron will have no time to be a tearaway, as his prissy wife will be keeping him in order.
And now I have reread my post I will do as Mr Weasley (Mark Williams) might have said, "I'll get me anorak"!!
By Christy APosted Monday 13th August 2007 13:24 GMT
<i>Congrats, you managed to introduce spoilers into an otherwise spoiler-free article.</i>
Really, anyone who hasn't read Deathly Hallows yet and is dim enough to click on anything labelled "Harry Potter" is going to get spoiled sooner or later, and I can't bring myself to feel sorry for them. The book has been out nearly a month.
I've read english private school stories before, and they're always incredibly myopic - most of them admit to no public schools, and many of them admit to very, very few other private schools. If they're so broad-minded that they admit to other countries, nearly all (if not all) other private schools will be located in other countries.
Combining this with the fact that magic hides so much even from practitioners of magic, I think it's fairly safe to say that there are actually hundreds, if not thousands, of magic schools in England - many of which the students at Hogwarts simply disregard if they're even aware of, and some of which the students at Hogwarts couldn't find out about because they're not in the right families, and don't have sufficient skill to locate - even if they tried, which they haven't. There is also the age-old practice of apprenticeship, which may still go on among the poorer practitioners of magic - although, given access to schools with multiple teachers, few would choose to have only one teacher.
Of course, there's still the problem that with all of these other schools, there are other joke sellers. We may not see them in the books - after all, nearly everywhere we've seen has either been muggle territory or Hogwarts territory, and it's doubtful that the author would even condescend to recognize the existance of people who graduated from "lesser" schools - but that doesn't mean they aren't there. Since most of the rest of the magical world would likely not be so fabulously wealthy, many of the Weasleys' competitors would probably have cheaper prices - possibly even much cheaper. There may not be many outside of the graduates of the schools mentioned in the books who would be willing to pay George and Ron's prices. However, there are probably plenty of practitioners of magic to help out the overall economy, and every so often, someone of lesser means may still save up to buy a genuine Weasley.
Comments on: Harry Potter and the Virus of Doom
Oh, please ! #
By Mark_T Posted Friday 10th August 2007 08:58 GMT
Not so rich? #
By Matt Robinson Posted Friday 10th August 2007 09:18 GMT
Economics of magic #
By Henry Gomersall Posted Friday 10th August 2007 09:32 GMT
Got to be said #
By Chris Morrison Posted Friday 10th August 2007 09:42 GMT
Your so wrong... #
By Rob Posted Friday 10th August 2007 10:13 GMT
Um... #
By Adam Bishop Posted Friday 10th August 2007 10:27 GMT
Several errors... #
By Lexx Greatrex Posted Friday 10th August 2007 10:27 GMT
Spoiler warning anyone? #
By Dan Posted Friday 10th August 2007 10:29 GMT
Well #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Friday 10th August 2007 10:44 GMT
Bizarre #
By Joe K Posted Friday 10th August 2007 11:43 GMT
Title #
By Christopher Emerson Posted Friday 10th August 2007 11:57 GMT
Harry Who? #
By Cameron Colley Posted Friday 10th August 2007 12:14 GMT
Good Idea for a Fan Fic Story #
By Kevin Eastman Posted Friday 10th August 2007 12:25 GMT
Lets hope.... #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Friday 10th August 2007 12:37 GMT
Yes, Minister for Magic #
By Robert Synnott Posted Friday 10th August 2007 12:57 GMT
Boadecia/Seven of Nine/Perfect Tens #
By amanfromMars Posted Friday 10th August 2007 13:41 GMT
So... #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Friday 10th August 2007 14:06 GMT
@Kevin Eastman #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Friday 10th August 2007 14:17 GMT
HUH ? #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Friday 10th August 2007 14:29 GMT
Been done, kinda #
By Saucerhead Tharpe Posted Friday 10th August 2007 15:11 GMT
Re: several errors #
By Dam Posted Friday 10th August 2007 16:11 GMT
Harry Potter and the Wankers at El Reg #
By Morely Dotes Posted Friday 10th August 2007 16:28 GMT
Liked it. #
By Purple Smurf Posted Friday 10th August 2007 16:28 GMT
isnt this website aimed at adults? #
By The Mighty Spang Posted Friday 10th August 2007 16:47 GMT
wtf? #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Friday 10th August 2007 16:51 GMT
@Robert Synnott #
By Jan Buys Posted Friday 10th August 2007 16:55 GMT
IT'S FRIDAY #
By Tim Posted Friday 10th August 2007 18:46 GMT
Spoiler? #
By J Posted Friday 10th August 2007 21:36 GMT
WTF - Personal blog? #
By Steven Hewittt Posted Saturday 11th August 2007 22:15 GMT
quidditch #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Sunday 12th August 2007 05:13 GMT
Head Auror #
By |333173|3|_||3 Posted Sunday 12th August 2007 16:11 GMT
amateur pedants #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Monday 13th August 2007 11:47 GMT
Re: amateur pedants #
By Andy Goodair Posted Monday 13th August 2007 12:48 GMT
Spoilers? Oh, please. #
By Christy A Posted Monday 13th August 2007 13:24 GMT
How many magic schools are there? #
By Ed Posted Monday 13th August 2007 14:01 GMT
Sorry 'bout that... #
By Geoffrey Summerhayes Posted Monday 13th August 2007 15:13 GMT