The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Warrantless wiretap opponents lose brace of court cases

Is it just me ? 

Posted Monday 9th July 2007 15:34 GMT

"The practice of so-called warrantless wiretapping came to light after the New York Times reported in December 2005 "

And what, exactly, did the good burghers of the USA think the NSA were doing *before* that ?

Is there seriously anyone in the US who honestly believed that the NSA was only ever spying on foreign interests and foreign nationals ?

I mean come one, you don't need an organisation that large just to nobble a few puny French aerospace deals.

phone number = URL ? 

Posted Monday 9th July 2007 15:51 GMT

while i can, to some extent, agree that there is a definite similarity between a phone number and a domain, it seems to me that http://domain.com/titleofdocument.html has a much more detailed information payload than 555-1234. I think this is another instance of inflexible cold-war-era laws being applied to technologies that are too complex for a good fit.

US Burghers 

Posted Monday 9th July 2007 16:56 GMT

Aren't that good. In fact they'll kill you pretty quick.

Ummm... 

Posted Monday 9th July 2007 20:44 GMT

"The plaintiffs said their concerns were well founded but the Wisconsin appeal court dismissed the case because none of the plaintiffs knew for sure whether or not their communications had been placed under surveillance."

Isn't that the issue? That no one knows how the wiretaps are being used? It wouldn't be very secret if the targets knew they were being tapped! I can tell you I'm glad I got out of the US and live in Canada now.

NSA Official Denial 

Posted Monday 9th July 2007 21:06 GMT

We were not listening.

You cannot not prove we were listening.

You are boring. We are not listening.

You now have a reason why we are not listening.

We will accept reasons to listen.

A small clarification 

Posted Tuesday 10th July 2007 13:05 GMT

Leyden writes: "...to intercept communications *inside* the US as part of the "War on Terror"."

John omits that the other end of these communications is *outside* the US with suspected bad guys.

Keep it real, John.

Don’t Miss

Win a Samsung C6625!

Reg Lucky Draw Windows Mobile handsets up for grabs

Palm_Pre_001_SMIs your cameraphone an oxymoron?

Pic Review iPhone 3G v iPhone 3GS v Palm Pre

Reg black vulture logoReg Mobile and Wireless newsletter is go! go! go!

Site news Email-tasm

Sign up, sign up for The Register IT security newsletter

Narrowcasting for the email classes