The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Father of LCD dies at 74

The Isaac Newton of our time? 

Posted Friday 25th May 2007 14:40 GMT

/de mortuis nil nisi bonum/, but surely "the modern Newton" is a bit overstated? Newton revolutionised our thinking in optics, mechanics and gravitation as well as (co-)discovering the calculus. Alongside which "contributed to the development of the LCD" (plus a walk-on part in a biopic, which unaccountably Newton never managed) looks a little weak to me.

Newton? 

Posted Friday 25th May 2007 15:23 GMT

All respect to prof. De Gennes, but surely calling him a modern day Isaac Newton is a bit excessive. After all, ground breaking work on liquid crystals is not quite the same as inventing Calculus and developing a model of force and motion that dominated scientific thinking for over 200 years!

Did he get 

Posted Friday 25th May 2007 15:38 GMT

a 74" coffin or go smaller with Bose speakers?

...sorry, I'll go home.

It is SUPERCONDUCTORS not supraconductors 

Posted Friday 25th May 2007 17:48 GMT

Supraconductors isn't even correct in French, where the french word for superconductors is "supraconducteurs".

Not so sure 

Posted Friday 25th May 2007 18:12 GMT

If Newton were alive today, I frankly doubt that he would have accomplished anything that would keep his name in the public mind for hundreds of years. As science gets more specific and esoteric, it becomes dramatically harder to make vast public discoveries that sound wowee-zing to the layman.

The alternative to calling people like him a modern day Isaac Newton is saying that we don't have any, and will, most likely, never have one again. Name one living scientist that more than, say, 5% of the US population can actually name off the top of their heads. And that's while they're alive!

Your alternatives are:

1) people are stupider today, universally. Or,

2) It's so much harder to make a useful discovery today that the people who are as smart as Newton, or nearly so, are reduced to nibbling at the fringe of knowledge.

-fred

If Newton were alive today ... 

Posted Friday 25th May 2007 21:27 GMT

... he'd be working on financial derivatives in the City, making a mint (sorry!)

The point is Newton was a genius who towered above his contemporaries. Now if someone called Roger Penrose "the modern Newton", they might have more of a point.

Re. Fred Fnord 

Posted Saturday 26th May 2007 08:42 GMT

But then again, less than 5% of the US population can correctly name the capital of China despite having bought hugh quantities of Chinese-made goods from their Wal-Marts, etc. !!

So I believe that your alternative 1) is correct when applied to the US !!

Penrose the new Newton? 

Posted Saturday 26th May 2007 09:40 GMT

Hardly. Maybe Dawkins - he seems paranoid enough about religion to be the equivalent (by the way, I'm an atheist).

"Supraconductors" is fine 

Posted Saturday 26th May 2007 09:46 GMT

Although largely replaced by the newer term "superconductor", materials with superconducting properties were referred to as supraconductors in all the early research, and the tem is still used interchngeably in some circles.

Where was STN LCD invented? 

Posted Saturday 26th May 2007 10:36 GMT

STN LCD made the commodity LCD market possible, didn't it? Prior to that LCDs weren't ever going to be affordable?

STN LCD was invented at RSRE Malvern, wasn't it? (And then in the usual British way commoditised elsewhere)

What kind of contributor doesn't mention Malvern/STN in an LCD-history-related article?

Stephen Hawking 

Posted Saturday 26th May 2007 15:10 GMT

There's your scientist more than 5% of the American public can name. But even Hawking shouldn't lay claim to being a modern Newton.

Missing from any article on the History of LCD 

Posted Saturday 26th May 2007 17:23 GMT

Pioneering work on liquid crystals was undertaken in the late 1960s by the UK's Royal Radar Establishment at Malvern. The team at RRE supported ongoing work by George Gray and his team at the University of Hull who ultimately discovered the cyanobiphenyl liquid crystals (which had correct stability and temperature properties for application in LCDs).

Ref: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_crystal_display

Penrose? 

Posted Tuesday 29th May 2007 00:10 GMT

> Now if someone called Roger Penrose "the modern Newton", they might have more of a point.

He fits the criteria - brilliant but a bit of a crank as a sideline.

Don’t Miss