The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Exam papers tagged to deter cheats

Motivation 

Posted Friday 11th May 2007 14:17 GMT

'It reckons the system should enable it to detect suspicious submissions from students by comparing their previous results for anomalies where a candidate "performs significantly out of line with expectations".'

There goes any motivation for studying hard and doing better next time...

Re: Motivation 

Posted Friday 11th May 2007 14:47 GMT

Yeah, that's total BS. They might as well ban re-takes... would that not motivate people to study hard and pass first time, because if they don't they're screwed for life?

Response to "Motivation" 

Posted Friday 11th May 2007 19:00 GMT

I am just about to take the GCSE's myself, and agree whole heartedly with the exam board. As they say, the mayhem it may well cause could take away from students. In response to the previous comments, I have never met, nor heard of a student going from an E to an A in the time of their mock to real GCSE exam, which is presumably the sort of jump that fits the criteria of "performs significantly out of line with expectations". They can hardly check everyone who knuclkles down and goes up a grade or two!

I don't get it. 

Posted Saturday 12th May 2007 09:32 GMT

This would work if leaks were from kids nicking papers when teachers weren't looking. A quick stock-check with an RFID wand would find the missing papers. I suspect however that the vast majority of leaks are direct from staff themselves armed with a photocopier. So how exactly would that stop leaks again?

Surely after all the years of schooling they'd have a large enough bank of questions to give each student a unique paper? That would at least reduce the impact of a leak.

As for "motivation," take a step back and have a look at todays GCSE's. It used to be the case that only the really clever 5% of students got a grade A. Nowadays, they're so pathetically easy, designed in this politically correct world to ensure that every white, black, brown, yellow, immigrant, stupid or clever person gets a pass they've lost their meaning entirely.

Response to response 

Posted Saturday 12th May 2007 12:55 GMT

"I have never met, nor heard of a student going from an E to an A in the time of their mock to real GCSE exam"

I confess, I only went from a D to an A in my GCSE Science mocks, but still. Whilst that may be because I never took any mocks seriously, I wouldn't want the exam board investigating me because of it.

Response the third 

Posted Saturday 12th May 2007 21:43 GMT

"I have never met, nor heard of a student going from an E to an A in the time of their mock to real GCSE exam"

I went from a G to a B in woodwork. The reason being a teacher who didn't like me refusing to mark most of my work. I eventually physically showed the head my work and the teacher quit shortly afterwards.

Let's hope... 

Posted Sunday 13th May 2007 10:19 GMT

The cheats don't discover technology like, err, digital cameras.

kiss 

Posted Monday 14th May 2007 10:42 GMT

we had a pretty secure system in my day - parcel addressed to headmaster, sent by registered post, complete with blue string and sealing wax.

AndyD 8-)#