Skip to content

Biting the hand that feeds IT

The Register ®


Related Whitepapers

Comments on ‘The Pirate Bay launches music sharing site’

Promises online musical treasure chest

Published Wednesday 2nd May 2007 10:39 GMT

« Back to article page

There is just one snag... 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Wednesday 2nd May 2007 11:42 GMT

"Last year, the popular file sharing network eDonkey agreed to pay $30m to settle a case brought by six music labels. P2P networks have succumbed one by one since the US Supreme Court ruled in June 2005 that file sharing services are illegal. "

There is just one simple problem with that. The US Supreme Court doesn't decide over Sweden. No matter how much the US may believe they're the rulers of the world, Sweden does have their own legal system and their own set of laws.

Survival of the fittest? 

By Phil
Posted Wednesday 2nd May 2007 19:45 GMT

"P2P networks have succumbed one by one since the US Supreme Court ruled in June 2005 that file sharing services are illegal. "

Bittorrent, which I have to say is my P2P medium of choice, appears to be surviving pretty well...

All that is achieved by bringing down one network is shifting its users to another. And as the easy targets are taken down, the harder ones will remain. The music lobby is fighting a losing battle, somewhat akin to the prohibitionists. People will find ways of getting what they want, the way they want it.

As much as they may spend time and resources trying to destroy it, there are more people, and probably more talented people willing to advance P2P technology. One day, 'untraceable' P2P may be a reality, and then the music industry is really up the creek...

The future is now 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Wednesday 2nd May 2007 21:44 GMT

"One day, 'untraceable' P2P may be a reality"

It's already a reality. I haven't bought a CD in 10 years.

whitepaper title

How IT Management Can "Green" the Data Center

This Gartner research provides managers with an outline of the trends affecting datacenters and offers strategies with which to address these changes..
whitepaper title

Gartner Paper: US Data Centers

U.S. enterprise data centers face considerable space and energy constraints over the next few years. Download this free independent report to read more..

Top 20 storiesAll The Week’s HeadlinesArchiveSearch