Why the world has lost interest in IPTV services
Is it feasible to deliver TV-quality video over IP?
Comment While doing the research for the very first issue of Faultline, one IPTV specialist (who shall remain nameless) told us "you can't send video across the web", and proceeded to lecture us on the finer points of Quality of Service protocols.
In a way he was right, but what he was saying lacked vision. The very next day at Faultline we were watching US made video over the internet, streamed from a German website to us in the UK. It seemed to work fine back then in 2002, and it's working better and better as people apply tiny improvements in technology to make it easier and cheaper to do.
What the IPTV specialist meant was that the reliability, resolution, and all round living room experience, was tough to achieve on the internet, and that IPTV was so much more. But it might not be for much longer.
As we look at predictions of widespread take up of IPTV, along with all other forms of Pay TV, what we've realided is that video delivered across the internet is a valid form of experience, but at the moment it's just a different experience from watching TV in your living room, and it can survive either by improving its quality or by remaining a separate experience living up to different rules. The question is just how far are we going to transition viewing habits that were formed in the living rooms of our families, back when we were kids, into new types of video experiences?
Within the industry we are all constantly arguing over issues like whether or not we will watch TV on a mobile phone, or asking what happens when your screen saver cuts in just as a key scene in a film appears, or how irritating the volume controls are on a PC, when what we should be thinking about is how to join up video experiences so they are a seamless whole, rather than a fragmented jitter of separate experiences.
Certainly, video is here to stay on the PC, YouTube has taught us that, although it is a fairly pointless, aimless, constantly searching, kind of one-off experience, which isn't worth repeating too often. And as Nokia begins a series of advertising pitches showing handsets doing incredible things, including showing TV, which are delivered with the caption "it's what the PC has turned into", it's obvious that we will soon be able to do all of the things on a handset that we only just recently found a PC could do.
The Holy Grail here is the cohesive delivery of programming to those three screens, where each screen has appropriate content in the sense that it is the type of content that viewers will be happy to view on that screen, and also in the sense the it is correctly sized and has the right codec treatment for delivery to that screen. But at the same time, cohesiveness needs to be delivered through some element of common programming, common access to services, both local on perhaps a set top, and remote, at a streaming server.
IPTV is a dead-end
I have to write here, I simply believe the concept of
IPTV is just a technical dead-end ...
At best a marketing wank for the couple of hundreds
blokes in London that have loads of bandwidth and
feel frustrating at nothing to occupy it with ...
Why on the nine hells, with all technical limitations
(end of local loop limiting bandwidth (I have 512 Kb myself),
ISPs bottlenecks, ISPs struggling to keep their network up
and running despite P2P) plus users wanting sensible
things (no latency for voIP, web., mail, games etc ...)
would anyone want to clobber his DSL bandwidth with
MB/s of TV/video when all channels are better available by
an one to all media like satellite ???
Even if I had 20MB/s, I woudln't do it, sparing the bandwidth
for better web access/downloading photos of nephew and
I say, get a sat dish, with a motor and enjoy hundreds of
Well speaking personally I'd want something that can playback on multiple devices more than once possibly several months or years later.
Basically what everyone has been doing with VCRs for twenty years or more.
DVD recorders and PVRs can do the same.
Anyone suggesting that you should be allowed to do this with IPTV (e.g. burn the content to a DVD for playback on any player) is treated as a potential criminal.
Content providers can't get over their love affair with DRM. They want to uninvent the VCR and offer services which are a massive step backwards in terms of convenience.
Can't possibly think why this should be unpopular...
Hmm it has been viable for years
After a popular show has finished someone always encodes it and uploads it to a nttp server, from which (with a small monthly fee) you can download binaries at the speed of your modem.
I have not seen the need for a Digital subscription for years and I get to watch my fav shows as they are released in the USA not having to wait for them to appear in the UK.