Researchers serve up obesity gene
Not the same as having fat bones, though
Researchers have identified a variant of a gene that, should you be blessed with two copies, makes you prone to retaining extra weight. Those with one copy of the mutant FTO gene are 30 per cent more likely to be obese, while those with two copies, the researchers say, are 70 per cent more likely to be dangerously overweight.
Unsurprisingly, this has prompted all kinds of hysterical headlines proclaiming that there really is a gene that explains obesity. You are not fat, one headline reads, you just have fat genes. Your genes are why you can't fit in your jeans, titters another.
But the research found that those with the double helping of the gene only weighed, on average, three kilos, or six and a half pounds more than those without. So the gene can't be blamed for all of the extra poundage Europe is hefting around.
In addition, the researchers still have no idea what the gene actually does that makes people predisposed to gain more weight than their non-gene carrying colleagues. Nevertheless the discovery that any gene is solidly associated with a tendency to pick up weight has got people very excited.
The researchers hope that the gene will help researchers discover new ways of preventing and treating obesity, and its associated illnesses.
The gene was identified while researchers were studying a group with type 2 diabetes. Sufferers are more likely to carry the variant of the so-called FTO gene.
The work, published in Science by the Peninsula Medical School and Oxford University, is based on data gathered from more than 38,000 people. From this data, the team was able to establish that the gene is also associated with extra weight. They estimate that around one in six white Europeans have two copies of the gene, while half will carry one copy. ®
But what's the mechanism
The press seem to be supposing that somehow having two copies of this gene make you more able to extract energy from food.So everyone else, through human history has been needlessly wasting some fraction of the food they eat for lack of the right gene?
Seems more likely that they've found the gene for greediness/laziness/indolence/dislike-of-sport or some such which is sure to correlate pretty well with having a few extra pounds.
Just another risk factor
Sadly the mainstream press seems unable to distinguish between a cause and a risk factor. This is no different from cancer genes like BRCA1, it simply increases risk of cancer not causes it (mutant BRCA1 actually causes cells to fail to repair DNA properly making any damage from external sources much more likely to lead to cancer).
As we all know the true cause of obesity is failure to wear your tinfoil hat, the population is so much easier to oppress when it can't muster the energy to get off its collective fat arse and oppose the govt
Not a complete surprise
I expect we all know people who seem to be able to eat large meals and take minimal exercise while remaining as thin as a rake. But the only way to lose weight (whatever your genetic code) is simple - eat less and/or exercise more.
As the old saw has it: "nobody came out of Belsen overweight" (though it's certainly possible that the only ones to come out of Belsen were those who were overweight when they went in).