The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Feeds

Games firm pursues 500 pinball 'pirates' through UK courts

18 ISPs served with court orders

Exclusive Zuxxez, the German games software distributor, has hired lawyers to chase down about 500 British file sharers, launching the first in a series of swoops by computer forensic experts.

Law firm Davenport Lyons will use this case, its first "volume" job to stalk file sharers, to launch a specialist practice. A partner at the firm, who preferred to remain anonymous for "security reasons" said Davenport had other publishers in the pipeline.

File sharers were reported under court orders served on 18 ISPs at Davenport's request after computer forensic experts associated their IP addresses as sources for downloaders of Dream Pinball 3D, a computer game that's unleashed in the UK - it goes on sale in June.

Letters sent to 500 file sharers in recent weeks recommended paying a £600 fine for sharing the £16.99 computer game on a peer-to-peer file sharing networks. Failure to pay would result in prosecution and potential court costs of "tens of thousands of pounds".

Harry Bilbao, who has received a letter from Davenport, dated 6 March, which accused him of file sharing, said in an email to The Register: "BIG problem is... I have no clue when it comes to law, I have no idea where I stand. Can you help?"

He said he had no knowledge of the game, had found there was a virus on his computer, had appealed against the threat and supplied evidence that there were viruses around that could commandeer your machine.

"I have looked for the game on my computer and I don't have it... And I don't remember ever playing it as I don't like pinball," he wrote.

Davenport replied in a letter dated 21 March: "In relation to your claim that your computer was hacked into, we regret that the security of your computer is not our concern. It is your responsibility to ensure that your computer is protected at all times."

The law firm gave Bilbao seven days to pay and sign a declaration promising never to share computer games again.

Davenport has a phone service for people worried about the threatened action, but the firm has told staff not to tell anyone their names. The letters they send out are not named.

A Davenport partner told The Register: "We don't give out names to infringers because we don't want to end up getting abuse on the phone."

The partner, and another who spoke about the campaign, said they were also worried about being threatened or spammed, and were worried about the welfare of their female employees.

But they admitted that the only calls that gave them concern had been ones from people demanding that they "speak with the engineer and not the oily rag".

In one instance, a file sharer had appeared at Davenport's offices, he said, although in this case it was a woman who just wanted some answers.

The partner refused to say how much his firm was being paid for pursuit of the file sharers, but the letter sent to them said £250 of the £600 fine being levied against them was to cover the solicitor's fee.

Dirk Hassinger, sales director at Zuxxez Entertainment AG, which holds the European licence for Dream Pinball 3D, said it had tried to find lawyers prepared to charge low fees because he didn't want to "bankrupt" file sharers. ®

Latest Comments

DO THIS for 100% proof that this is a scam i will proof it!

VERY IMPORTANT I MEAN IT

i have not even recieved a single letter myself

but i have been 4 steps ahead and acted for myself

by getting to the bottom of this so im prepaired.

i know you don't know me from adam but for the people who's had these letters its a scam and i will prove it now!

By doing what i tell you to do now you have nothing to lose but i assure you i am 100% right.

if im not 100% right im sure you'll just come back and blacken my name but i assure you if you trust me you'll do this.

If your on virgin/cable do the following.

Call Virgin media company Ask to speak to a lady called Moreen Davies on Extension 6140 -

She will explain everything too you

OFFCOM has been in liason with the CAB over this now this past few weeks since this scam has been going on

She will advise you exactly what to do ALSO all their other staff members in the office has also even had letters themselves you are advised not to ignore them but to do the following.

Contact the person above, she will then tell you to send a copy of the letter to NCLC Virgin media PO BOX 333 Matrix Court SAJ 9BB

You then need to contact offcom yourself + watch dog.

if your on any other isp then contact the manager directly dont let them pass you to pillar to post.

get in touch with manager and i guarentee you they will all of been infromed about this.

0
0

I didnt do it

I'm 100% sure I never downloaded this, I use wireless but has wpa 128bit encryption - i know my stuff about pcs and sure i never downloaded THIS game.

email me if you have any information for me Rocky9861@hotmail.com

0
0

I'm Just Glad

I'm just glad that I made the decision a few years ago not to use closed-source software anymore. Since then, I've been running an "i-tal" GNU/Linux system* and loving it.

Honestly, how many more reasons does anyone need not to use closed-source software?

* (Well, mostly. I do confess to using Flash player, though installed in a sandbox and not system-wide, and Java before it went GPL. OTOH, I'm using the Open Source "nv" drivers for my graphics card. It's important to me that my kernel stays pure.)

0
0
Anonymous Coward

Message for Mr Lee Dowling

Mr Lee Dowling, ( Or anyone who can Help)

I am Harry Bilbao, the one having all these problems..

Do you specialise in law of this nature?

I need some help with this

Thanks

Harry

E Mail is: Harry@Bilbao.com

0
0

Reasonable costs

"Dirk Hassinger, sales director at Zuxxex Entertainment AG, which holds the European licence for Dream Pinball 3D, said it had tried to find lawyers prepared to charge low fees because he didn't want to "bankrupt" file sharers"

I find it hard to believe that they couldn't find a legal firm prepared to charge less than £125,000 for sending out 500 letters!

Since no cases have been officially opened yet this is all they can really charge for surely? Unless they have had 3 reasonably well paid solicitors working full time for the past 6 months researching this non-starter of a case! Perhaps if someone has the guts and resources to take them to court they can ask for the costs to be justified as well.

0
0

More from The Register

Android is a mess and needs sprucing up, admits chief
Can Google really fix it? It isn't in control any more
New Lumia 925: This, loyalists, is the BIG ONE you've waited for
Nokia veep drills high-end master plan for El Reg
Android device? Ooohhhh, you mean a Samsung phone
Koreans nabbed nearly all the Q1 profits – more even than Google
Review: HP Pavilion 14 Chromebook
All roads lead to Chrome?
Borked your iDevice? Pay EVEN MORE to have it fixed by Applecare
Or scream at their hapless techies on their forums
Euro PC shipments plummet into bottomless pit of DOOOOM
11th quarter of decline, 20pc drop on last year - Gartner
MIT takes battery-powered robot cheetah for a gallop
Biomimetic big cat needs no power cord, just a walker