The French Ministry of Defense has reportedly raised a red flag on OpenOffice, saying the open source desktop suite is less secure than Microsoft's product.

A classified report by the ministry into OpenOffice has apparently concluded the suite is more susceptible to attack from macros than Microsoft Office.

Publication of the report comes as OpenOffice sees growing use in government circles across Europe as an alternative to Microsoft's Office. Recent converts in France include the Direction Generale des Impots - rolling out OpenOffice to 80,000 clients ripping out Office 97 - and the French gendarmerie with 104,275 personnel.

The report is unlikely to dampen enthusiasm for OpenOffice and will no-doubt be brushed aside by supporters of the suite as something the community can fix. Indeed, the MoD is expected to present its findings to OpenOffice.org.

Supporters will also, rightly, point to the shameful security record of Microsoft Office. Malware writers have gone beyond just Outlook to crack open Word, Excel and PowerPoint as a means to gain control of users' PCs.

That said, you can be sure the existence of the report will be seized upon by critics of OpenOffice and open source as proof "we told you so." Furthermore, you can expect a slow uptick in numbers of exploits. The Stardust poof of concept virus was recently written to exploit macros in Sun Microsystems's StarOffice, anchored on OpenOffice, but can be modified for OpenOffice 2.0.®

Related stories

• Malware targets OpenOffice users (22 May 2007)
• OpenOffice hits back at viral risk claims (15 August 2006)
• Flaw finders lay siege to Microsoft Office (22 July 2006)
• When PowerPoint presentations attack (17 July 2006)
• OpenOffice update fixes security bug trio (3 July 2006)
• MS June update fixes dangerous Word flaw (14 June 2006)
• First StarOffice malware sighted (1 June 2006)
• MS advises users to play safe with Word (24 May 2006)
• Trojan exploits unpatched Word vulnerability (22 May 2006)
• Critical MS patch fixes graphics bugs (9 November 2005)
• Open Office 2.0 beta arrives (2 March 2005)
• MS launches Office security blitz (4 September 2003)
• MS ‘Security Framework’ is another .NET vulnerability (14 November 2001)