Feeds

C++/CLI: a paradigm too far

Microsoft's new albino jumbo

Internet Security Threat Report 2014

No denigration without substantiation

To see why, let us a take a step back. C++ is notoriously complex. Whereas smaller computer languages have features designed into them, C++ is unusual in having a whole swathe of functionality discovered, like a tract of 19th century Africa. Nobody intended that C++ should support template metaprogramming, a wildly clever but visually dismal technique that allows the programmer to write a program within the program. One day it was noticed that it could be done, and now it is done.

Microsoft has taken this giant of a language, clamped it down on the target platform of their linguistic accelerator, and bombarded it with .NET fragments travelling at 10,000mph. The resulting 'tuple' (to use Stan Lippman's word, perhaps chosen because Boost doesn't yet offer a 'chimera') is the aesthetic equivalent of the monster in the original Quatermass - a man with one arm melted into a cactus plant.

Consider the issue of pointers. Pardon me while I instruct you briefly in ovoid evacuation by vacuum, Grandma. C++ offers two basic kinds: the common-or-garden kind, represented by a *, and the reference kind, that you aren't supposed to think of as a pointer until you must, represented by a &. Famously a source of confusion for novice programmers, and, cough, their elders can occasionally come unstuck too. One problem is: two kinds is really one too many. The superfluity steams up the lens.

But these constructs don't work in the safety-scissors-and-glitter .NET world, where ordinary pointers are usually concealed beyond reach. So with C++/CLI you get two more kinds in the packet, represented by ^ and %, which approximately map .NETty things on to the traditional * and &. So suddenly you've got parallel sets of pointy things, governed by different rules. Oh, great.

But it's not just pointers. There are special declarations for all the .NET classes and structs and interfaces. There is a new kind of generic mechanism. There are arrays that nearly behave like std::vectors... but not quite. If you are fond of destructors, there's now an extra one with a ! in front of it that your object gets long after death, when it has served its term in purgatory. And heaps extra - well, one heap anyway. Go look for yourself.

Another thing. Here are some demonstrative fragments of code from the same Lippman article, comparing C# and C++/CLI syntax for class declaration.

abstract class Shape { ... } // C#
ref class Shape abstract { ... }; // C++/CLI
struct Point2D { ... } // C#
value class Point2D { ... }; // C++/CLI

Notice anything? The C++/CLI version is just a little bit more wordy and clumsy than its C# equivalent; because its 'spaced' keywords have to be squeezed into the cracks. Use a .NET feature, you pay a cruft tax.

C++/CLI isn't a natural extension of C++; rather it is a dual gauge system. The detritus from two incompatible programming models is crammed uncomfortably into one space. The thing to remember about dual gauges is that, while any fool can do a straight bit, it's the points that will eventually put paid even to a Brunel.

Microsoft must run on its dual gauge system if it is to make a success of Windows Vista. But we don't.

If you need to write for .NET in a curly brackets language, may I suggest you try C#? It's focused and elegant and fits snugly into its design hole - just right for those webby-databasey back end apps that define, to Microsoft's irritation, the .natural .NET .niche.

And if you need to come back to something that runs a little edgier, and is more widely scoped, and lets you blow your leg off whenever you want, then C++ will still be there for you out here in the real world. Promise. ®

Secure remote control for conventional and virtual desktops

More from The Register

next story
ONE MILLION people already running Windows 10
A third of them are doing it in VMs, but early feedback focuses on frippery
Sign off my IT project or I’ll PHONE your MUM
Honestly, it’s a piece of piss
Netscape Navigator - the browser that started it all - turns 20
It was 20 years ago today, Marc Andreeesen taught the band to play
Torvalds CONFESSES: 'I'm pretty good at alienating devs'
Admits to 'a metric ****load' of mistakes during work with Linux collaborators
Sway: Microsoft's new Office app doesn't have an Undo function
Content aggregation, meet the workplace ... oh
Do Moan! MONSTER 6-day EMAIL OUTAGE hits Domain Monster
Customers freaked out by frightful service
Ploppr: The #VultureTRENDING App of the Now
This organic crowd sourced viro- social fertiliser just got REAL
Return of the Jedi – Apache reclaims web server crown
.london, .hamburg and .公司 - that's .com in Chinese - storm the web server charts
NetWare sales revive in China thanks to that man Snowden
If it ain't Microsoft, it's in fashion behind the Great Firewall
prev story

Whitepapers

Forging a new future with identity relationship management
Learn about ForgeRock's next generation IRM platform and how it is designed to empower CEOS's and enterprises to engage with consumers.
Win a year’s supply of chocolate
There is no techie angle to this competition so we're not going to pretend there is, but everyone loves chocolate so who cares.
Why cloud backup?
Combining the latest advancements in disk-based backup with secure, integrated, cloud technologies offer organizations fast and assured recovery of their critical enterprise data.
High Performance for All
While HPC is not new, it has traditionally been seen as a specialist area – is it now geared up to meet more mainstream requirements?
Saudi Petroleum chooses Tegile storage solution
A storage solution that addresses company growth and performance for business-critical applications of caseware archive and search along with other key operational systems.