The UK Patent Office has called for worldwide consultation on the fundamental principles of patenting to tackle growing doubt in the efficacy of the IP approval system.

The British patent system is thought to work rather well in comparison to the US system, which has a reputation for awarding trivial or ridiculous patents, and the European system, which is trying to rebuild its reputation after an exhausting three-year squabble over software patents.

It appears that the latter is the motivation both for this consultation and the wider Gowers review of Intellectual Property that was launched in December.

At least in official circles, there is no lack of pride in the purity of the British system. Both reviews were tempered at their launch by official claims that there is nothing wrong, but that is no reason to neglect checking the knots and greasing the wheels, even if British patent law is set for the most part at the EC.

Reviews of the British system now will not only protect it against powerful lobbies that would have it operate differently, but would strengthen its reputation, and therefore encourage innovators at a time when patent is a dirty word. It would also strengthen the British position in any move toward a worldwide system or in negotiations in Europe.

Patents Directorate deputy director Hugh Edwardes, who launched the review, says the reputation of the US system and the controversy over software patents prompted this "fundamental" review.

"People say they're not worth the paper they're written on, like the famous Amazon one-click buy. People think it brings the patent system into disrepute if you grant patents like that," he says.

Page:

• 1
• 2
• Next →

Related stories

• Incoming EPO president reopens software patent debate (4 July 2007)
• Patent applications to be peer reviewed? (15 December 2006)
• Music industry will take copyright battle to Europe (7 December 2006)
• Gowers: crack down on pirates (6 December 2006)
• Updated Copyright extension a no-go: BPI reacts (27 November 2006)
• Shock record industry poll: Brits like British musicians (13 November 2006)
• IBM wades into Amazon for patent infringement (23 October 2006)
• Poll: 55% break copyright law (12 May 2006)
• Gowers warned over patent review (5 May 2006)
• Anti software patents lobby agrees with arch enemy (16 March 2006)
• Java Bytecode patent allowed in UK law (14 March 2006)
• Microsoft hands out patent protection to mobile chums (9 February 2006)
• RIM prepares to post ban-beating Blackberry update (9 February 2006)
• Four-year 'limited patent' proposed (6 February 2006)
• Patent oracle speaks (3 February 2006)
• RIM defeats InPro - again (2 February 2006)
• Auction planned for 1,000 patents (27 January 2006)
• Mistakes found in 98% of US patents (20 January 2006)
• Software patents loom large again (17 January 2006)
• IBM looks to patent new system for patenting patents (12 January 2006)
• Intel backs RIM in Supreme Court appeal bid (12 January 2006)
• Nokia and Kyocera resolve patent dispute (10 January 2006)