Research in Motion (RIM) has prevailed in a patent infringement legal battle in Germany, the company said today. Like its better-known fight with US intellectual property holding company NTP, RIM's tussle with Luxembourg-based InPro centres on allegations that it used, without permission, technology patented by InPro.

However, the German Federal Patent Court in Munich today ruled that InPro's German-registered patent, European Patent EP 0892947B1, is invalid.

InPro may yet appeal the decision by asking the German Federal Supreme Court to adjudicate.

InPro filed a lawsuit against RIM in November 2003. RIM countersued, asking the court to rule that InPro's patent claims were invalid. It also alleged InPro has demonstrated "threatening and grasping behaviour". ®

Related stories

• Lawsuits in Motion settles one more lawsuit (16 July 2009)
• RIM defeats patent appeal challenge (8 February 2007)
• RIM's 3G Blackberry launch imminent (24 March 2006)
• RIM puts $613m settlement in motion (3 March 2006)
• Blackberry ban decision 'soon', says judge (25 February 2006)
• Microsoft hands out patent protection to mobile chums (9 February 2006)
• RIM prepares to post ban-beating Blackberry update (9 February 2006)
• Four-year 'limited patent' proposed (6 February 2006)
• Patent oracle speaks (3 February 2006)
• RIM defeats InPro - again (2 February 2006)
• O2 hops on Blackberry 8700g bandwagon (2 February 2006)
• Date set for Blackberry ban hearing (26 January 2006)
• T-Mobile preps UK launch for Blackberry 8700g (24 January 2006)
• Supremes shun RIM - again (24 January 2006)
• RIM: US economy up spout if Blackberry shut out (19 January 2006)
• RIM reveals free Mac Blackberry sync software (13 January 2006)
• Intel backs RIM in Supreme Court appeal bid (12 January 2006)
• BlackBerry squeezed by DoS security bugs (4 January 2006)