Feeds

BitTorrent inventor lambasts Avalanche 'vaporware'

Not a product you can use or test

  • alert
  • submit to reddit

Build a business case: developing custom apps

Bram Cohen, inventor of the BitTorrent file-sharing protocol, has launched a stinging attack on Microsoft's "Avalanche" peer-to-peer system unveiled (sort of) last week by its Cambridge (UK) researchers.

In a posting on his blog, Cohen - whose protocol is (over?)estimated to be responsible for one-third of the world's internet traffic - criticises Avalanche for about as many things as you can shake a good-sized stick at.

"Avalanche is vaporware," he begins. "It isn't a product which you can use or test with, it's a bunch of proposed algorithms. There isn't even a fleshed out network protocol. The 'experiments' they've done are simulations. It's a bad idea to give much weight to simulations, especially of something so hairy as real-world internet behavior."

Certainly, anyone who was at the presentation last week of the Avalanche concept would have come away thinking it was a here-now, working-in-the-lab product. (We certainly did.) The truth, it turns out, is that Avalanche is study of strategies and principles of how a file-swarming system could be made to work well.

In his demolition of the "vaporware" (a neat trick in itself), Cohen begins by pointing out that the online paper with the Microsoft group's criticism of his own protocol is, at best, seriously out of date because it points up problems with BitTorrent that were removed by a rewrite "back in 2001". "In their simulations [of how BitTorrent works, or doesn't] peers have 4-6 neighbors with a strong preference for 4. BitTorrent in the real world typically uses 30-50." That effectively hobbles his baby, and the simulation doesn't look at other variables - "varying transfer rate abilities or endgame mode" - so that "intentionally or not, the simulation is completely rigged against BitTorrent."

And there's more: "One thing badly missing from this paper is back-of-the-envelope calculations about all of the work necessary to implement error correction." Particularly, he says, if the file being transferred is bigger than the memory available, you'll end up thrashing your disk as you try to recombine your whole file to send it to the next peer.

He concludes that "I think that paper is complete garbage. Unfortunately it's actually one of the better academic papers on BitTorrent, because it makes some attempt, however feeble, to do an apples to apples comparison. I'd comment on academic papers more, but generally they're so bad that evaluating them does little more than go over epistemological problems with their methodology, and is honestly a waste of time."

We asked Peter Key, joint manager of the Networks and Performance group at Microsoft Cambridge, to respond. Emphasising firstly that he doesn't want to get into a slanging match with Cohen or about BitTorrent, he acknowledged that yes, Avalanche is presently a research project that isn't publicly available to test, and that it relies on simulations to compare how it would work with existing file-sharing systems.

"Of course simulations are always going to be abstract; we're trying to understand the principles here," Key said. "And we aren't trying to develop a generalised file-sharing system. Precisely what it will be used for would be up to the product group." Quite when - or if - Avalanche would appear is uncertain too.

But Key points out that one of the important problems with file-swarming (a la BitTorrent) that Avalanche aims to solve is that of "poisoned" swarms, whereby a malicious peer can upload a little bit of a file, or change part of a file, which will then be propagated to peers. That needs error correction, which Cohen admits is tough. Microsoft's Key, by contrast, says that a focus of the Avalanche project is "securing the integrity of the files". One thing you can be sure of: there's no risk of downloading a virus from vaporware. Then again, there's not much risk of downloading anything from vaporware. ®

Related stories

StreamCast updates Morpheus P2P with BitTorrent
For every DRM download, 16 P2P swaps
Supremes silent on Grokster case
Adware makers exploit BitTorrent
Enter Avalanche: P2P filesharing from Microsoft

Next gen security for virtualised datacentres

More from The Register

next story
Video of US journalist 'beheading' pulled from social media
Yanked footage featured British-accented attacker and US journo James Foley
Caught red-handed: UK cops, PCSOs, specials behaving badly… on social media
No Mr Fuzz, don't ask a crime victim to be your pal on Facebook
Ballmer leaves Microsoft board to spend more time with his b-balls
From Clippy to Clippers: Hi, I see you're running an NBA team now ...
Kate Bush: Don't make me HAVE CONTACT with your iPHONE
Can't face sea of wobbling fondle implements. What happened to lighters, eh?
Amazon takes swipe at PayPal, Square with card reader for mobes
Etailer plans to undercut rivals with low transaction fee offer
Microsoft exits climate denier lobby group
ALEC will have to do without Redmond, it seems
Assange™: Hey world, I'M STILL HERE, ignore that Snowden guy
Press conference: ME ME ME ME ME ME ME (cont'd pg 94)
Call of Duty daddy considers launching own movie studio
Activision Blizzard might like quality control of a CoD film
US regulators OK sale of IBM's x86 server biz to Lenovo
Now all that remains is for gov't offices to ban the boxes
prev story

Whitepapers

Implementing global e-invoicing with guaranteed legal certainty
Explaining the role local tax compliance plays in successful supply chain management and e-business and how leading global brands are addressing this.
Top 10 endpoint backup mistakes
Avoid the ten endpoint backup mistakes to ensure that your critical corporate data is protected and end user productivity is improved.
Top 8 considerations to enable and simplify mobility
In this whitepaper learn how to successfully add mobile capabilities simply and cost effectively.
Rethinking backup and recovery in the modern data center
Combining intelligence, operational analytics, and automation to enable efficient, data-driven IT organizations using the HP ABR approach.
Reg Reader Research: SaaS based Email and Office Productivity Tools
Read this Reg reader report which provides advice and guidance for SMBs towards the use of SaaS based email and Office productivity tools.