Toshiba takes Hynix to task in patent clash

Lawsuits filed after licensing talks collapse

For Sale sign detail

Toshiba has accused Hynix of infringing its DRAM and Flash patents, and has begun legal proceedings against its South Korean rival in the US and Japanese courts.

A lawsuit filed with the Tokyo District Court alleges Hynix wilfully infringed three of Toshiba's NAND Flash patents. The Japanese company wants the court to block the sales of allegedly infringing components and to force Hynix to cough up damages for the transgression.

A second suit, filed in the US District Court for Northern Texas, alleges infringement of four NAND patents and three others relating to DRAM. Again, Toshiba is seeking an injunction against offending products.

Both cases follow the collapse of talks between the two companies over the extension of an August 1996 semiconductor intellectual property cross-licensing deal. That agreement expired on 31 December 2002, and negotiations centring on the terms of a new agreement have been going on ever since.

Hynix has yet to formally respond to its erstwhile licensing partner's action, but given that the falling-out concerns a cross-licensing deal, Hynix will almost certainly accuse Toshiba of infringing some of its intellectual property and fire off one or more counter-suits.

Toshiba's action comes a week after Matsushita and LG Electronics began a tit-for-tat lawsuit exchange, with both companies claiming the other has infringed their plasma display panel patents. Fellow Japanese memory maker Renesas is also pursuing Taiwan's Nanya through the courts, claiming its own DRAM patents have been infringed. ®

Related stories

Graphics patent holder sues Sony, MS, Nintendo
3D patent suit extended to Dell, HP, IBM, Sony, others
Game makers hit with graphics patent violation suit
Dell sued for alleged global sales patent abuse
LG, Matsushita trade lawsuits in PDP patent clash
Nvidia accused of patent violation
Renesas seeks Nanya DRAM ban
NEC, Toshiba moot anti-Hynix, anti-dumping complaints

Sponsored: Network DDoS protection