BT and CPW in £1,000 challenge showdown
Gloves off, cash at stake
The Carphone Warehouse's (CPW) pledge that if it ain't cheaper than BT it'll cough up £1,000 could be about to be tested following BT's claim that it is now cheaper than CPW.
BT says that Carphone has raised some bill-paying charges to £3.50 a month, while the monster telco insists it only charges people who don't pay by direct debit just £1 extra.
Plus, the UK's dominant fixed line telco says that some of its tariffs are now cheaper that CPW's TalkTalk service, based on analysis from comparison site uSwitch.com. As a result, it's egging on TalkTalk punters to take up a challenge made by CPW boss, Charles Dunstone, in April who boasted: "We are so convinced TalkTalk will save you money over BT, if we can't prove it, we'll give you £500."
Since then, the cash on offer has doubled to a cool grand with CPW claiming "Cheaper than BT Guaranteed! Or we'll give you £1,000". Now BT has decided to face the "challenge" head-on and is calling Dunstone's bluff.
Tough-talking BT exec, Gavin Patterson said: "They made a big play of offering £1,000 to any BT customer who changed to Carphone Warehouse and wasn't better off as a result. Well we think it might be interesting for people to take Charles Dunstone at his word and see if they can relieve him of £1,000.
"Carphone Warehouse has scored a bit of an own goal by charging customers who don't pay by direct debit an extra £3.50 a month. Our prices were already great value and within a whisker of the cheapest available. These charges mean that for some people who want to see the bill before writing a cheque BT will now be cheaper than Carphone Warehouse," he said.
A spokeswoman for CPW said: "We don't understand Gavin's point. Direct debit is mandatory to join TalkTalk: if you can't pay by direct debit you can't be a TalkTalk customer. This is made very clear if you try to join TalkTalk on the site [uSwitch.com] referred to by BT. ®
BT punters flee
Carphone Warehouse has a good quarter
Carphone Warehouse in minimum wage 'sting'
One.Tel in free calls offer
BT fires gimmick salvo at Carphone Warehouse
Carphone Warehouse declares war on BT
Carphone Warehouse in free call offer
Sponsored: Network DDoS protection