GPL will not pass the legal test -SCO
Stalking SGI
Posted in Hardware, 2nd October 2003 11:26 GMT
Free whitepaper – GPFS Sequential I/O performance
The SCO Group is extending its royalty campaign to encompass Silicon Graphics Inc. The company says it will revoke SGI's Irix license on October 14. It's no surprise, as SCO CEO Darl McBride has explicitly mentioned SGI over a month ago. SGI signed the license with AT&T in 1986.
SGI's response is exactly the same as IBM's, when threatened with revocation. The Mountain View systems company says the license is paid for and irrevocable. When SCO revoked IBM's license, IBM countersued and simply carried on selling AIX.
Is SCO serious? The news emerged from of a SEC filing by Silicon Graphics. SCO didn't trumpet its intentions in a press release.
On Monday, however, SCO responded to IBM's amended case, which explicitly cites SCO's violations of the GPL, the General Public License. SCO's press release with a line which will seem very familiar to Register readers. "The GPL has never faced a full legal test, and SCO believes that it will not stand up in court. We are confident that SCO will win the legal battle that IBM has now started over the GPL."
Eben Moglen responded to our concerns on this last month, observing that Richard Stallman - who drafted the GPL - had created a license "more elegant and robust than he could have foreseen." We'll belatedly publish your thoughtful responses to this later today. ®
Related Stories
GPL goes to court
The GPL will win, claims law prof.
Against SCO’s GPL jihad: one size doesn't fit all
Free whitepaper – Fundamental Principles of Air Conditioners for Information Technology

The Register Agile Data Center Summit
Dell PowerEdge R710 solution with VMware ESX vs. Dell PowerEdge 2850 solution
Seven ways to lower storage costs
IBM System Blue Gene/P solution brochure
Microsoft Windows Server 2008 Hyper-V on Sun Fire x64 servers

Cisco to counter HP with Chinese expansion
Microsoft is developing its own cloud storage O/S
Seagate takes skinniest single platter to Vegas
Symantec's bumper bonus bells and whistles