‘I Married an Extropian’ – reader

DARPA's brains trust unravelled

  • alert
  • submit to reddit

Providing a secure and efficient Helpdesk

Letters Admiral Poindexter reappeared to defend the Pentagon's Terror Casino (PAM) this week. Our coverage provoked a few letters, and some corrections. Extropians aren't rich.

A small footnote to history - the more famous of the two founders of Extropianism is from Britain; he is a friend of mine from university, and we tend to have a flurry of exchanging emails once or twice a year.

We visited him and the co-founder in glamorous South Central L.A. in the late 80s, when they were both graduate students at U.S.C. If they had lots of money or rich backers they certainly concealed it well. The same is pretty much true today, as far as I know. I believe he is comfortably off but he is hardly the Maharishi. Robin Hanson (not to be confused with Robin Hansen - author of 'Knit Mittens - 15 Cool Patterns to Keep You Warm') is as you note an associate professor, hardly a great money spinner.

Extropians, like Libertarians, seem rarely to be actually rich - they are more interested in 'making money' in the abstract rather than making money (without quote marks) in the particular.

The 'ideas futures' idea was one they seemed very keen on back in the late 80s. I was not surprised to see one of this group being behind it, but I was too lazy to research it, so thanks for your article.

I have personally long felt that Libertarianism and related beliefs have something to do with poor potty training. Most people come rapidly to the conclusion that governments are, as with all human endeavours, the product of flawed humans, rather than a body of selfless people working tirelessly in the public interest, they then move on and get on with their lives ignoring the government when appropriate, trying to intervene when appropriate etc.. Libertarians, however, seem to get caught at this 'ohmigod it's not fair' stage and continue to bang on about it ad nauseum.

I am probably preaching to the choir here, but to me it seems that the main reason the computer / software / whatever you want to call it industry punches well below its weight vs. e.g. the entertainment industry / the military-snooping complex / Fortune 500 companies outsourcing everything to the developing world, is the fondness for the libertarian 'stick fingers in the ears and repeat 'it's not fair, you're interfering with the market, let the market decide' trope.

Clearly there is research to be done here on the geek / libertarian / Aspergers / potty training nexus, but I feel sure that research dollars would be more than well spent if they lead to a cure.

John Styles

It's amusing, in a slightly sad way, to see the more naive sort of economist - Hanson and the other proponents of PAM - earnestly declaring their faith in the predictive power of the market. As Robert Heilbroner (himself an economist, though of a stripe that is not popular these days, at least in the US) points out in Twenty-First Century Capitalism, economists nicely failed to predict pretty much every major economic event of the last century (the fall of the Soviet Union, for example). And if the markets predicted them, they did so in a marvelously obscure and subtle fashion. How many market analysts correctly read its augury of the dot.com bubble collapse?

It was published a few years too early to include the Extropians, but Ed Regis' _Great Mambo Chicken and the Transhuman Condition: Science Slightly Over the Edge_ (Addison Wesley, 1990) remains an entertaining and informative introduction to various transhumanist ideas and proponents. Some of the people Regis profiles are nice enough folks with decent, if underdeveloped, ideas - Eric Drexler, for example - or basically harmless, like Hans Moravec. Others (the fans of recreational explosives) are dangerous but probably mostly in a small way. A few, or their compatriots, may have started to gain real power, like Hanson and the Extropians.

Regis sees many of these folks as suffering from "fin de siecle hubristic mania", which is as neat a phrase as I could come up with for it (and considerably politer than most of my efforts).

I heard Katherine N. Hayles give a talk once about "artificial life" researchers. She noted that they leaned heavily on ideas about "emergent phenomena" - basically, that when you lump enough stuff together, the whole does more than what you'd expect from the sum of its parts. It's their favorite narrative. Like so many best-loved stories, though, it doesn't appear to need any connection to the real world.

Michael Wojcik

Are you channelling Bill O'Reilly, or are you an Extropian yourself, merrily taunting the Entropians of your readership?

Enquiring minds want to know.

Tyler Holcomb

Related Stories

Kill a Middle East head of state, win prizes! - Pentagon shows how
Pentagon pulls Kill-An-Arab futures trading website
Meet the 'transhumanists' behind the Pentagon terror casino

Security for virtualized datacentres

More from The Register

next story
Are you a fat boy? Get to university NOW, you PENNILESS SLACKER
Rotund types paid nearly 20% less than people who didn't eat all the pies
Emma Watson should SHUT UP, all this abuse is HER OWN FAULT
... said an anon coward who we really wish hadn't posted on our website
Japan develops robot CHEERLEADERS which RIDE on BALLS
'Will put smiles on faces worldwide', predicts corporate PR chief
Bruges Booze tubes to pump LOVELY BEER underneath city
Belgian booze pumped from underground
Oz carrier Tiger Air takes terror alerts to new heights
Don't doodle, it might cost you your flight
Amazon: Wish in one hand, Twit in the other – see which one fills first
#AmazonWishList A year's supply of Arran scotch, ta
Let it go, Steve: Ballmer bans iPads from his LA Clippers b-ball team
Can you imagine the scene? 'Hey guys, it's your new owner – WTF is that on your desk?'
Oi, London thief. We KNOW what you're doing - our PRECRIME system warned us
Aye, shipmate, it be just like that Minority Report
prev story


A strategic approach to identity relationship management
ForgeRock commissioned Forrester to evaluate companies’ IAM practices and requirements when it comes to customer-facing scenarios versus employee-facing ones.
Storage capacity and performance optimization at Mizuno USA
Mizuno USA turn to Tegile storage technology to solve both their SAN and backup issues.
High Performance for All
While HPC is not new, it has traditionally been seen as a specialist area – is it now geared up to meet more mainstream requirements?
Beginner's guide to SSL certificates
De-mystify the technology involved and give you the information you need to make the best decision when considering your online security options.
Security for virtualized datacentres
Legacy security solutions are inefficient due to the architectural differences between physical and virtual environments.