Tweaks to service make Hotmail messages look like spam

Er, so? - Ed

Updated Changes in the way some Hotmail messages are formatted could make legitimate emails sent using the service harder to distinguish from spam.

Hotmail messages composed with alternative fonts or colours no longer feature multipart/alternative headers and are instead sent as pure HTML emails.

This recent change is making life more difficult for admins fighting the spam tsunami, if Reg's reader James Masterton experience is anything to go by.

MSH Hotmail denies making any recent changes but without speaking to its techies we're not convinced.

Spammer tricks

Sending MIME-encoded pure HTML is a common spammer trick to fool text-based filters.

Because of this sites frequently have a server policy in place to refuse SMTP transmission of pure HTML emails.

But Hotmail messages are now being sent as pure HTML, so some sites are inadvertently blocking Hotmail messages, Masterton reports.

Users are complaining, but if Microsoft relaxes the policy, then more spam is likely to make its way through.

So Masterton (and many others, we suspect) is faced with a dilemma.

Kill or cure

The changes introduced by Hotmail mean many spam filtering services might need tweaking.

There are so many packages, services and techniques for blocking spam (all with varying - imperfect - levels of effectiveness) that's its hard to say how big a deal this might be, but since Hotmail has such a huge user base it would appear foolish to do nothing.

Alex Shipp, of email filtering specialists MessageLabs, reckons that unless changes are made more legitimate emails will be blocked.

"Packages like SpamAssassin currently count such [pure HTML] messages as highly likely to be spam," he told us.

"So this new policy, while saving MS lots of bandwidth, could backfire on them as Hotmail users inadvertently find their emails blocked."

MessageLabs itself is reviewing whether its own filters need tweaking because of Hotmail's recently introduced changes.

Update

Hotmail’s development team, through Microsoft’s UK Press Office, has finally got back to us (a day late) to say no such changes have been made to its service.

Since this response contradicts what security experts are telling us we wanted to speak to MSN directly. The MS spokeswoman said she couldn’t provide give us either a phone number or even contact email (for "confidentiality reasons") of Hotmail’s developers this is rather difficult. We don’t blame her for this, incidentally. She is trying to help but her hands are being tied. ®

Related Stories

Hotmail, Yahoo! erect roadblocks for spam sign-ons
We hate Spam (email your friends)
MS paper touts Unix in Hotmail's Win2k switch
MS addresses Hotmail spam blizzard. At last
Hotmail charges for POP email
Messenger Pop-up Spam makes us sick
Plaid up in arms as Commons spam filter bans Welsh

Sponsored: 10 ways wire data helps conquer IT complexity