W3C rejects net patent tax, avoids web schism
PrintRAND banned
Posted in Music and Media, 16th November 2002 01:32 GMT
Free whitepaper – PowerEdge energy Smart brochure
The web standards consortium W3C has agreed on a policy that should prevent nasty royalty surprises for developers in the future.
The latest draft from the W3C's patent policy group stipulates that participants must agree to license patents on a royalty-free basis. W3C-blessed web standards have always been royalty-free, but last year the W3C countenanced a twin-track approach, adding RAND licensing as an option.
It met with a fierce response from software libre developers, with talk of creating a breakaway organization that could set royalty-free standards. Developers are reluctant to start work on a technology with the threat of possible lawsuits and fees hanging over them, and for GPL developers it's a no-no: the license forbids developers from working with encumbered technology.
The new draft, which had input from the FSF's Eben Moglen and Bruce Perens, should avert a schism by eliminating the RAND track altogether. So there's no way that a technology could begin life as a royalty-free license then switch to a fee-bearing license during the ratification process.
The W3C allows patent holders to "retain defensive use of their patents". The W3C expects this to be ratified by next May. ®
Related Link
Related Stories
Net patent tax - W3C publishes new advice
Berners Lee: WWW royalties considered harmful
IBM risks billion dollar Linux strategy with W3C RAND demands
W3C denies misleading world+dog on RAND license status
We'll fork the Web to keep it Free - Perens
W3C defends RAND license
The free Web's over, as W3C blesses Net patent taxes
The Register Agile Data Center Summit
Analyst Keynote: The Register Agile Data Center Summit
Analyst Keynote: The Register Agile Data Center Summit
Dirty, dirty PCs: The X-rated picture guide
Top 500 supers - rise of the Linux quad-cores
Early adopters bloodied by Ubuntu's Karmic Koala
Sign up, sign up for The Register IT security newsletter