The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Feeds

Broader surveillance won't prevent terrorism -Schneier

Interpretation

  • print
  • alert

Customer Success Testimonial: Recovery is Everything

The clamour for wider surveillance measures has been deafening in the wake of September 11.

To date, opponents against such moves have argued mostly on civil liberties grounds. But the case against can also be made on the grounds that more surveillance simply won't work.

That's the analysis of Bruce Schneier, founder and chief technology officer of Counterpane Internet Security, who says the failure to anticipate the September 11 attacks was one of data interpretation, not of data collection.

Speaking today at the Information Security Solution Europe conference in London, he drew parallels between Internet security and physical security to make his point that more widespread monitoring is in itself unlikely to prevent terrorism.

"You can either build a system right or build it wrong and watch everybody," he said. "Broad surveillance is generally the sign of a badly designed system of security."

Instead of relying on collecting more data (signals intelligence), counter terrorism agencies should put more effort into human intelligence, he argues. "The Stasi collected data on four million East Germans, roughly one fourth of their population. Yet they failed to predict the fall of the Berlin Wall because they invested too heavily in data collection and too little in data interpretation and human intelligence."

According to Schneier, it is possible - but not easy - to improve security without harming privacy and liberty. Something approaching robust and resilient security could be achieved by combining prevention, detection. There's a chance to redesign our "public infrastructures for security", he said. ®

Ensure Ease of Recovery with Asigra’s Agentless Software

More from The Register

 breaking news
NSA PRISM-gate: Relax, GCHQ spooks 'keep us safe', says Cameron
Whatever they are up to, it's all above board, we're told
PRISM snitch claims NSA hacked Chinese targets since 2009
Snowden suddenly looks safer in Hong Kong after revelations
 breaking news
US chief spook: Look, we only want to spy on 6.66 BEELLLION of you
Americans assured they are not in the NSA's sights
Speech-to-text drives motorists to distraction
Will talking to you mean I crash into that car up ahead, Siri?
DHS warns of vulns in hospital medical equipment
Has your doctor's anasthesia machine been hacked?
 breaking news
Yes, maybe we should keep hackers in the clink for YEARS, mulls EU
Watch out black hats, they just might throw away the key
Microsoft borks botnet takedown in Citadel snafu
Stupid Redmond kicked over our honeypots, wail white hats
Critical Java SE update due Tuesday fixes 40 flaws
And yes, most are remotely exploitable
NSA accused of new crimes ... against slideware
They may take our information but they cannot take our REFINED AESTHETICS