The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

What's this button here do?

A case for idiot-proof OSes?

Increase your knowledge of the latest threats to your busines

Windows XP will make Internet unstable - top security expert

In the above article, Steve Gibson claims that Windows XP threatens to make the Internet unstable. Apparently, the problem lies in allowing people to launch uncontrollable denial-of-service attacks to whichever IP address they see fit.

Fahd Arshad has a point to make about such operability:

No offense to Mr. Gibson - I don't consider myself in a position to offend someone of his standing anyway - but the argument he makes is rather odd. One of Microsoft's attitudes that has come under fire repeatedly is their patronizing the common user a.k.a. the Win9x owner etc.

Their security model often simply blocks users from doing things Microsoft considers they aren't "responsible enough to handle". As a CS student who needs flexibility in computing, this does irk me sometimes, but I also understand that most users that I have come across as a lab and residential computer consultant, no offense to them, need just that because if their computers were any more complicated than a microwave to operate, they would either be confused or give up on them altogether, not because they are dumb but because of the aura of mystique that surrounds computers. I digress.

My point was that Mr. Gibson seems to be advocating a similar role for application developers: develop for the "real" users, and develop for everyone else. Not that I believe that's a completely wrong argument, but I'd be interested to know what Mr. Gibson and all the other punters think of crippling the consumer version of the OS... MS would have to, considering Win2000 and XP are going to share the same code base.

Does anyone know if WinXP has instructions on how to operate our office microwave? The coffee's gone cold...

Join our expert panel in discussing application security

Don’t Miss

Win a Samsung C6625!

Reg Lucky Draw Windows Mobile handsets up for grabs

Palm_Pre_001_SMIs your cameraphone an oxymoron?

Pic Review iPhone 3G v iPhone 3GS v Palm Pre

Reg black vulture logoReg Mobile and Wireless newsletter is go! go! go!

Site news Email-tasm

Sign up, sign up for The Register IT security newsletter

Narrowcasting for the email classes