Dopey surgeon loses $200k on dud deal – sues E-Trade, and wins

Stupid greedy people need looking after

A stock speculator who blew $200,000 on a foolish dotcom buy has successfully sued online broker E-Trade.

Jay Kiessling was awarded $203,333.15 after a panel of the National Association of Securities Dealers decided E-Trade processed the buy order without caring about the risks for its customer, the Chicago Sun-Times reports.

Kiessling, a surgeon from Alabama, lost the cash two years ago when he bought shares in Theglobe.com, a company that personalizes Web pages.

The company had just ended an IPO at $9 per share, and a brief stock market frenzy sent its share price rocketing. But trading in the stock was halted that day - something Kiessling was not told - and although he bought a stack of shares at between $84 and $86 a share, by end of the day the price had dropped to around $30. (In today's cyber-sceptic market, investors can pick up one of Theglobe.com's shares for around 78 cents.)

Kiessling felt he had been denied crucial market information - and that E-Trade had broken its contractual promise to stop customers from trading beyond their means. He had a margin account with E-Trade, which let him borrow up to half the cost of the stock he wanted from the online broker. At the time of the purchase, his account allowed a maximum $144,000 buy, but E-Trade let the order slip through for around $422,000.

"Be very careful with these online brokers," said Kiessling, who still has an E-Trade account. "When they say they're offering the same service as a [conventional] broker, they're not. You're giving up a lot more than simply high brokerage fees."

E-Trade pleaded innocence, saying its systems could not stop Kiessling's order. ®

Related Stories

E-Trade security hole still not bunged
Psion falls 25 per cent on profit warning
Vodafone and Verizon ditch IPO plans
Wall Street savages Priceline.com

Sign up to our Newsletter

Get IT in your inbox daily

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2017