Judge limits copyright settlement payout

Damages limitation exercise may not suffer as much as it expected to after losing a copyright violation suit brought against it by the Recording Industry Association of America earlier this year.

The trial judge, US District Judge Jed S Rakoff, this week ruled that when it comes to calculating the damages must pay to music labels only the number of CDs it used, not the number of songs, will be taken in account.

That could cut the amount has to pay out by a factor of ten. Each copyright has infringed could lead to statutory damages anywhere between $750 and $30,000. Since, had up to 80,000 CDs in its database, you can see why it might well breathe a sigh of relief that damages will be limited to discs not songs. has spent the months since the trial, which took place in April, negotiating with the major labels, on whose behalf the RIAA brought the suit. Earlier this week, the company settled with Sony, paying an undisclosed sum to settle the case and to license the label's catalogue. Last month it struck a similar deal with EMI, following arrangements with BMG and TimeWarner. Some industry observers claim has paid each company $20 million.

That just leaves Universal to settle with, but a deal can't be too far off, possibly even before the 28 August hearing at which's damages will be decided.

The hearing follows Judge Rakoff's verdict that's 'virtual CD player' service,, which allowed CD owners to listen to their library of discs from any PC, anywhere, did infringe copyright holders' rights, even though the listener had a legal right to copy their own albums for personal use.'s mistake was to build a commercial operation out of the service. ®

Related Stories

EMI and sort it out loss balloons after lawsuit costs
Indie label sues for copyright theft vs RIAA judge explains his verdict
Court finds guilty of copyright violation

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2017