Feeds

RIAA dubs Napster defence ‘patently baseless’

Issues response to MP3 company's attack on copyright case

  • alert
  • submit to reddit

Combat fraud and increase customer satisfaction

The Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) yesterday responded to Napster's defence, released last week, against the organisation's copyright violation lawsuit.

Both defence and response have been posted in the run-up to a 26 July hearing at which the judge will decide whether the RIAA should be granted an injunction against Napster forcing the company to remove all works owned by RIAA member companies from its service.

Napster argues that the RIAA case for such an injunction is groundless on three counts. First, allowing users to share MP3 files isn't illegal, provided its users do so non-commercially. Second, Napster's software, also called Napster, is simply the code equivalent of a VCR, and precedent has permitted them to be sold. Finally, the RIAA's attempt to block Napster from operating is itself a violation of anti-trust law.

Not surprisingly, the RIAA poo-poos all three arguments. Napster's first line of defence is based on the US' Home Recordings Act of 1992. It allows anyone who buys a CD to make a tape copy to play it in the car or on a Walkman. That tape can also be shared with others, and Napster reckons sharing MP3s amounts to the same thing.

The RIAA points out that, in documents on the Home Recordings Act authored before the law's enactment, only "a household and its normal circle of friends, rather than the public" can legally share copies of copyright works. That, says the RIAA, clearly negates Napster's 'sharing-is-legal' claim.

"The truth is, the making and distributing of unauthorised copies of copyrighted works by Napster users is not 'sharing', any more than stealing apples from your neighbour's tree is 'sharing'," says the RIAA brief.

One other point, says the RIAA, the Home Recordings Act doesn't apply to computers and computer-based services. It should know: that's the very argument Diamond Multimedia lawyers used to prevent the RIAA getting the company's Rio MP3 player banned.

As for the VCR argument, the RIAA says the comparison with Napster is false - Napster is a business service, not a product. True, Napster's software is a product, but the basis of Napster's operation is to make money by selling advertising to its users. VCRs were declared legal because although they could be used for copyright infringement, they could also be used for perfectly legitimate purposes - in short, their manufacturers don't profit directly from the illegal use of their products. Napster, on the other hand, does, at least according to the RIAA.

"Napster is no more subject to (these legal protections) than would be a defendant whose business consisted of providing customers with a VCR, copyrighted movies, and a room in which to copy them," the RIAA brief states.

Finally, the RIAA notes that in the MP3.com copyright infringement trial, also instigated by the RIAA, that company claimed that the RIAA's action against it was a violation of anti-trust law because it sought to block the actions of a new competitor. The trial judge dismissed MP3.com's line as " frivolous", and the RIAA reckons Napster's identical argument should be thrown out for the same reason.

Napster and its high-profile advocate, David 'Microsoft anti-trust trial' Boies, also claim that the company, as an ISP, is protected from its users' actions by the US' Digital Millennium Copyright Act. The only snag here is that this argument has already been dismissed by a Federal Judge last month. It also implies that Napster's users may be engaged in illegal acts that Napster is, as an ISP, safe from. Yet Napster's main defence is that its users aren't acting illegally. That's a contradiction the company has yet to resolve. ®

Related Stories

Napster details copyright case defence
RIAA counter-sues pernickety Web site over MP3 links
Napster tries to talk its way out of RIAA suit
DoJ's top gun from MS trial joins Napster defence
US shies from unwanted Net music legislation
US musos unite against Net piracy
Philips to unite MP3 and CD technology

3 Big data security analytics techniques

More from The Register

next story
Ubuntu 14.04 LTS: Great changes, but sssh don't mention the...
Why HELLO Amazon! You weren't here last time
This time it's 'Personal': new Office 365 sub covers just two devices
Redmond also brings Office into Google's back yard
Next Windows obsolescence panic is 450 days from … NOW!
The clock is ticking louder for Windows Server 2003 R2 users
Half of Twitter's 'active users' are SILENT STALKERS
Nearly 50% have NEVER tweeted a word
OpenBSD founder wants to bin buggy OpenSSL library, launches fork
One Heartbleed vuln was too many for Theo de Raadt
Got Windows 8.1 Update yet? Get ready for YET ANOTHER ONE – rumor
Leaker claims big release due this fall as Microsoft herds us into the CLOUD
Batten down the hatches, Ubuntu 14.04 LTS due in TWO DAYS
Admins dab straining server brows in advance of Trusty Tahr's long-term support landing
Red Hat to ship RHEL 7 release candidate with a taste of container tech
Grab 'near-final' version of next Enterprise Linux next week
Apple inaugurates free OS X beta program for world+dog
Prerelease software now open to anyone, not just developers – as long as you keep quiet
prev story

Whitepapers

Mobile application security study
Download this report to see the alarming realities regarding the sheer number of applications vulnerable to attack, as well as the most common and easily addressable vulnerability errors.
3 Big data security analytics techniques
Applying these Big Data security analytics techniques can help you make your business safer by detecting attacks early, before significant damage is done.
The benefits of software based PBX
Why you should break free from your proprietary PBX and how to leverage your existing server hardware.
Securing web applications made simple and scalable
In this whitepaper learn how automated security testing can provide a simple and scalable way to protect your web applications.
Combat fraud and increase customer satisfaction
Based on their experience using HP ArcSight Enterprise Security Manager for IT security operations, Finansbank moved to HP ArcSight ESM for fraud management.